“PEACEFUL” EXPANSION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION IN UKRAINE (1991 – 2014)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.35.332676Abstract
The purpose of the research is to study and elucidate the process of Russia’s territorial expansion in Ukraine in 1991 – 2014 and the role of the pro-Russian political and public agents of influence in it. The research methodology is based on the general scientific principles of historicism, objectivity and systematicity. There have been used general scientific methods: analysis, synthesis, periodization and the others, as well as special methods of historical research: historical genetic, historical systemic, historical comparative. The scientific novelty of the obtained results consists in the comprehensive analysis of the process of the so-called “peaceful” expansion of the Russian Federation in Ukraine in 1991 – 2014, without use of the armed force. Taking into consideration some separate examples, it has been proved that the war of the Russian Federation against Ukraine has historical roots from the beginning of its declaration of independence in 1991. The relations between Russia and Ukraine, as two sovereign states, during this period were not good-neighbourly, but were accompanied by constant territorial claims on the part of the Russian Federation, as open, and veiled, through the pro-Russian political parties, separatist movements, religious organizations, and other political and public agents of influence. Conclusions. The Russian aggression against Ukraine began in 1991 after its independence. The main goal of the Russian “peaceful” expansion was the destruction of sovereign and independent Ukraine or, in the event of its unreachability, keeping it under its control within a single “union” space. In order to achieve this goal, Russia imposed political, economic, religious, cultural, informational, military and other pressure with the wide use of technologies of subversion, blackmail, lies, intimidation, provocations, etc. Russia masked its own participation in destructive processes in Ukraine and carried out expansion through various pro-Russian political parties and organizations, representatives of criminal oligarchic groupes, separatist movements, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) and some of its ministers, pro-Russian media and other agents of influence, who operated under Russian special services management. In 1991 – 2014, during the Russian expansion in Ukraine, there were distinguished two conditional stages. The first stage, from August 26, 1991 to September 29, 2003, from the right of the Russian raising the issue on revising the state borders of the postsoviet republics, if they do not coexist within the unified space of the Union. It was considered to be the biggest crisis in the Russo-Ukrainian relations at the time, when Russia resorted to the use of force against Ukraine before the conflict had broken out regarding Kosa Tuzla Island. The second stage took place from September 29, 2003 to February 20, 2014, which began with the conflict around Kosa Tuzla Island, ended with the termination of the so-called “peaceful” expansion after the Revolution of Dignity in 2014, and then the beginning of the Ukrainian Crimea and Sevastopol occupation. There are several cites on the separate provisions of regulatory legal acts of Russia and Ukraine in the article, which strengthens the author’s argumentation and outcomes on a chosen topic.
Key words: Russian Federation, Ukraine, hybrid warfare, Russo-Ukrainian war, expansion, territorial expansion, agents of influence, separatism, occupation of Crimea, self-proclaimed organizations “DPR” and “LPR”.
References
Adamovych, S. (2007). Dialog mizh Galychynoyu i Donbasom u period rozpadu SRSR [Dialogue between Galicia and Donbass during the collapse of the USSR]. Stosunky Shodu ta Zahodu Ukrainy: subiekty, interesy, cinnosti / Ed. I. F. Kononov, (pp. 10–20). Lugansk: Znannya. [in Ukrainian].
Akt progoloshennya nezalezhnosti. (1991). Akt progoloshennya nezalezhnosti Ukrainy [Dialogue between Galicia and Donbas during the collapse of the USSR]. Postanova Verxovnoyi Rady Ukrainskoui RSR “Pro progoloshennya nezalezhnosti Ukrainy” vid 24 serpnya 1991 roku № 1427-XII. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1427-12 [in Ukrainian].
Alejnikova, S. M. (2017). “Russkij mir”: geopoliticheskij podhod [“Russian World”: a geopolitical approach]. Vescі BDPU, 2 (1), 41–47. [in Russian].
Aleksiievets, L., & Aleksiievets, M. (2020). Transformatsiia vidnosyn Ukrainy ta NATO v 1991 – 2019 rr.: istorychnyi aspect [Transformation of relations between Ukraine and NATO in 1991–2019: historical aspect]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian historical journal, 1, 126–142. [in Ukrainian].
Allenova, O., Geda, E., & Novikov, V. (2008). Blok NATO razoshelsja na blokpakety [The NATO bloc has split into block packages]. Komersant, 57, 9. URL: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/877224 [in Russian].
Analitik. (2013). Analitik Putina priznalsja, zachem Rossii nuzhna Ukraina [Putin's analyst admitted why Russia needs Ukraine]. From-UA.com. URL: https://from-ua.com/news/277583-analitik-putina-priznalsya-zachem-rossii-nuzhna-ukraina.html [in Russian].
Baskakova, A. (2023). Polityko-pravovyi status mista Sevastopolya na terytorii Ukrainy: istorychnyi aspekt [Political and legal status of the city of Sebastopol on the territory of Ukraine: historical aspect]. Sobornist Ukrayiny: istoriya ta suchasnist: Materialy Vseukr. nauk. konf., (pp. 149–155). Kyiv–Nizhyn: Vydavec Lysenko M. M. [in Ukrainian].
Boiko, O. (2004). Ukraina v ostanni misiaci imperiyi (serpen – gruden 1991 r.): hronika ta analiz [Ukraine in the last months of the empire (August – December 1991): chronicle and analysis]. Lyudyna i polityka, 3, 74–82. [in Ukrainian].
Budet li. (2004). Budet li Doneckaja respublika? [Will there be a Donetsk Republic?]. Poisk, 49, 5. [in Russian].
Do vojny. (2020). “Do vojny za Tuzlu byla para soten metrov”. Kuchma nazval samyj slozhnyj moment za kadenciju [“Until the war in Tuzla, it was a hundred meters.” Kuchma called the most difficult moment of his tenure]. Lіga. Novini. URL: https://news.liga.net/politics/news/do-voyny-za-tuzlu-byla-para-soten-metrov-kuchma-nazval-samyy-slojnyy-moment-za-kadentsiyu [in Russian].
Dohovir pro druzhbu. (1997). Dogovir pro druzhbu, spivrobitny`cztvo i partnerstvo mizh Ukrainoiu i Rosiiskoiu Federaciyeiu vid 31 travnia 1997 r. (ratyfikovano Zakonom N 13/98-VR vid 14.01.1998) [Treaty on Friendship, Cooperation and Partnership between Ukraine and the Russian Federation of 31 April 1997 (ratified by Law No. 13/98-VR of 14.01.1998)]. URL : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/643_006 [in Ukrainian].
Dohovir. (2003). Dohovir mizh Ukrayinoiu i Rosiiskoiu Federaciyeiu pro ukrainsko-rosijskyi derzhavnyi kordon vid 28.01.2003 r. [Agreement between Ukraine and the Russian Federation on the Ukrainian-Russian State Cordon dated 28.01.2003.]. URL : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/643_157 [in Ukrainian].
Feoktistov, S. (2005). Politicheskaja karma Viktora Ja [Political karma of Victor Ya]. From-UA. URL: https://from-ua.org/articles/7569-politicheskaya-karma-viktora-ya.html [in Russian].
Furman, I., & Duz-Kryatchenko, O. (2019). Ekspansiya Rosiiskoyi Federaciy v Ukraini 1991 – 2014 rr. yak skladova zagalnoyi strategiyi likvidaciyi ukrainskoi derzhavnosti [The expansion of the Russian Federation in Ukraine 1991 – 2014 as part of the overall strategy for the liquidation of Ukrainian statehood]. Voyenno-istorychnyi visnyk, 4 (34), 46–67. [in Ukrainian].
Glava administraciyi. (2003). Glava administraciyi Putina zayavyv, shho ne postupytsya Kerchenskoyu protokoyu i skyne tudy bombu [The head of Putin's administration stated that he would not follow the Kerch Protocol and would drop a bomb there]. Kreshhatyk. URL: http://kreschatic.kiev.ua/ua/2363/art/15028.html [in Russian].
Golod, I. (2011). SRSR № 2. Yak Ukrayinu namagalysia vtyagnuty u novyi Soyuz [USSR No. 2. How Ukraine managed to get involved in the new Soyuz]. Istorychna pravda. URL: https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2011/12/26/66360/ [in Ukrainian].
Gorbulin. (2016). Gorbulin dokladno proanalizuvav, yak Rosiya rokamy gotuvalasya do agresiyi proty Ukrayiny. Navit masova kultura – element vijny [Gorbulin thoroughly analyzed how Russia was preparing for aggression against Ukraine for years. Even mass culture is an element of war]. Teksty.org.ua. URL: http://texty.org.ua/pg/news/textynewseditor/read/65583/Gorbulin_dokladno_proanalizuvav_jak_Rosija_rokamy_gotuvalasa#comments [in Ukrainian].
Grabovskyi, S. (2014). I znovu PISUAR [And again PISUAR]. Den. URL: http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/blog/politika/i-znovu-pisuar [in Ukrainian].
Haldej, A. (2018). Rossija vserjoz vzjalas za integraciju byvshego sovetskogo prostranstva [Russia has taken up the integration of the former Soviet space seriously]. IA REGNUM. URL: https://regnum.ru/news/polit/2500906.html [in Russian].
Haliv, M., & Burdyak, R. (2025). Putin i Hitler: porivnialni konstruktsii v ukrainskomu mediinomu dyskursi (2014 – 2025) [Putin and Hitler: Comparative Constructions in Ukrainian Media Discourse (2014 – 2025)]. Axis Europae, 6, 108–130. DOI: 10.69550/3041-1467.6.326256 [in Ukrainian].
Hrytsiuk, V., & Lysenko, O. (2023). Viina Rosiiskoyi Federaciyi proty Ukrainy: voyennyi, mizhnarodno-pravovyi, geopolitychnyi ta ekonomichnyi vymiry [The Russian Federation's war against Ukraine: military, international legal, geopolitical and economic dimensions]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian Historical Journal, 2, 5–33. [in Ukrainian].
Hula, R. V., & Perederii, I. H. (2017). Rosiiskyi fashyzm: ideolohichni osnovy, istoriia stanovlennia ta suchasni modyfikatsii. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian Historical Journal, 2, 160–182. [in Ukrainian].
Informaciyno-analitychni materialy. (2023). Informaciyno-analitychni materialy shhodo ekspansiyi Rosijskoyi Federaciyi v Ukrayini u 1991–2023 rokax [Information and analytical materials on the expansion of the Russian Federation in Ukraine in 1991–2023]. Kyiv: NUOU. [in Ukrainian].
Jankovskij, A. (2016). “Russkij mir” Sergeja Lavrova: pust sosedi bojatsja [“Russkij mir” by Sergey Lavrov: pust sosedi bojatsja]. Krym. Realii. URL: https://ru.krymr.com/a/27513360.html [in Russian].
Kazanskyi, D. & Vorotynceva, M. (2020). Yak Ukraina vtrachala Donbas [How Ukraine lost Donbas]. Kyiv: Knyzhkove vydavnyctvo “Chorna gora”. [in Ukrainian].
Kliuchnyk, R. (2011). Separatyzm yak svitova megatendenciya suchasnosti [Separatism as a global megatrend of our time]. Politychnyi menedzhment, 6, 120–128. [in Ukrainian].
Konstytuciya. (1978). Konstytuciya (Osnovnyi zakon) Ukrainskoi Radianskoi Socialistychnoi Respubliky. Pryinyata pozachergovoyu somoyu sesiyeiu Verhovnoi Rady Ukrainskoi RSR deviatogo sklykannya 20 kvitnya 1978 roku [Constitution (Basic Law) of the Ukrainian Radian Socialist Republic. Adopted at the extraordinary third session of the Verkhovna Rada of the Ukrainian RSR of the ninth convocation on April 20, 1978]. URL: https://zakononline.com.ua/documents/show/159896___159896 [in Ukrainian].
Kopylenko, O. (2004). Krym yak nevidyemna skladova chastyna Ukrayiny: pravovi aspekty [Crimea as an integral part of Ukraine: legal aspects]. Krym v istorychnyh realiyah Ukrainy: Materialy nauk. konf., (pp. 5–35). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Kramar, O. (2012). Nas shtovhayut u PiSUAR [We are being watched by PiSUAR]. Tyzhden.ua. URL: https://tyzhden.ua/Politics/66863 [in Ukrainian].
Kravchenko, V. (2019). “Nam by akvatoriju vzjat da podelit” [“We should just take the water area and divide it up”]. ZN.UA. URL: https://dt.ua/international/nam-by-akvatoriyu-vzyat-da-podelit-326098_.html?fbclid=IwAR1KFy7pNWWAgjJN12qJey807incaWMo33tpegtnl4RBWOd8o5LfqLd4hrY [in Ukrainian].
Kreml. (2014). Kreml rassmatrivaet 4 scenarija po otnosheniju k Ukraine – eks-sovetnik Putina [Kremlin is considering 4 scenarios regarding Ukraine – Putin`s ex-advisor]. UNIAN. URL: https://www.unian.net/politics/879306-kreml-rassmatrivaet-4-stsenariya-po-otnosheniyu-k-ukraine-eks-sovetnik-putina.html [in Russian].
Kushnariov. (2004). Kushnariov realno ogolosyv avtonomiyu Harkivskoi oblasti [Kushnariov really declared the autonomy of the Kharkiv region]. Ukrainska pravda. URL: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2004/11/27/3004729/ [in Ukrainian].
Lavrov. (2016). Lavrov: RF ne narushala Budapeshtskij memorandum [Lavrov: Russia did not violate the Budapest Memorandum]. KorrespondenT.net. URL: https://korrespondent.net/world/russia/3620273-lavrov-rf-ne-narushala-budapeshtskyi-memorandum [in Russian].
Lugansk. (2004). Lugansk robyt krok nazad ta vidhreshhuietsia vid rishennia vidokremytys? [Lugansk is taking a step back and seeing the beauty of the rich?]. Ukrayinska pravda. URL: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2004/11/26/3004716/ [in Ukrainian].
Lyubovec, O. (2023). Persha sproba aneksiyi Krymu u 1990-x rokax yak proyav imperskyh ambiciy Rosijskoyi Federaciyi [The first attempt to annex Crimea in the 1990s as a manifestation of the imperial ambitions of the Russian Federation]. Sobornist Ukrainy: istoriya ta suchasnist: Materialy Vseukr. nauk. konf., (pp. 140–149). Kyiv–Nizhyn: Vydavec Lysenko M. M. [in Ukrainian].
Malko, R. (2022). Rozvidka boiem. Yak 2003 roku Rosiia sprobuvala zahopyty pershyi klaptyk ukrainskoi zemli [Reconnaissance through combat. How Russia tried to seize the first piece of Ukrainian land in 2003]. Tyzhden. URL: https://tyzhden.ua/History/254954 [in Ukrainian].
Melnychuk, I. (2014). Derzhavy postradyanskoho prostoru v suchasnyh heostratehichnyh dokumentah Rosiyskoi Federaciyi [The states of the post-Soviet space in current geostrategic documents of the Russian Federation]. Naukovi zapysky Instytutu politychnyh i etnonacionalnyh doslidzhen im. I. F. Kurasa, 3(71), 315–325. [in Ukrainian].
Memorandum. (1994). Memorandum pro garantiyi bezpeky u zviazku z pryiednanniam Ukrainy do Dohovoru pro nerozpovsyudzhennya yadernoyi zbroyi vid 5 grudnia 1994 r. [Memorandum on security guarantees in connection with Ukraine's accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, dated 5 December 1994.]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/998_158#Text [in Ukrainian].
Moshenec, O. (2020). Identyfikaciya “Borna”, abo Hto taki agenty inozemnogo vplyvu [Identification of “Borne”, or Who are the agents of foreign influence?]. LB.ua. URL: https://lb.ua/blog/olena_moshenets/459027_identifikatsiya_borna_abo_hto_taki.html [in Ukrainian].
Myhalchyshyn, Yu. (2022). Hto taki agenty vplyvu. 15 klyuchovyh tez [Who are these agents of influence? 15 key theses]. Glavkom. URL: https://glavcom.ua/columns/mikhalchishin/khto-taki-ahenti-vplivu-15-kljuchovikh-tez-902660.html [in Ukrainian].
Nashyvochnikov, O. & Pashkova, O. (2020). Ekspansiya Rosiiskoyi Federaciyi v kulturnij sferi Ukrainy: istorychnyi dosvid [The expansion of the Russian Federation in the cultural sphere of Ukraine: historical experience]. Tendances scientifiques de la recherche fondamentale et appliquée, (vol. 2, pp. 123–125), Strasbourg, République française. [in Ukrainian].
Nykonorov, O. (2015). Istoriya rozvytku separatyzmu v Doneckiy oblasti [History of the development of separatism in the Donetsk region]. Depo.Donbas. URL: https://dn.depo.ua/ukr/donetsk/istoriya-rozvitku-separatizmu-v-donetskiy-oblasti-28102015090000 [in Ukrainian].
O gosudarstvennoj politike. (1999). O gosudarstvennoi politike Rossiskoi Federacii v otnoshenii sootechestvennikov za rubezhom. Federalnyi zakon ot 24 maja 1999 g. № 99-FZ [On state policy of the Russian Federation in relations with foreign economic operators. Federal Law of May 24, 1999 No. 99-FZ]. URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20140312022927/http:/russkg.ru/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=84:lr&catid=11:2010-07-31-13-40-54&Itemid=12 [in Russian].
O pravovoj ocenke. (1992). O pravovoj ocenke reshenij vysshih organov gosudarstvennoj vlasti RSFSR po izmeneniju statusa Kryma, prinjatyh v 1954 godu. Postanovlenie Verhovnogo Soveta Rossijskoj Federacii ot 21 maja 1992 goda №2809-1. [On the legal assessment of decisions of the highest organs of state power RSFSR on changing the status of Crimea, adopted in 1954. Postanovlenie of the Supreme Council of the Russian Federation of May 21, 1992 №2809-1]. URL: http://www.memory.gov.ua/publication/dokumenti-parlamentiv-ukraini-ta-rosii-1990-kh-rokiv-shchodo-statusu-krimu-ta-mista-seva [in Russian].
O prodolzhenii raboty. (1992). O prodolzhenii raboty po izucheniju pravovoj obosnovannosti reshenij Prezidiuma Verhovnogo Soveta SSSR ot 19 fevralja 1954 g. i Verhovnogo Soveta SSSR ot 26 aprelja 1954 g. o vyvedenii Krymskoj oblasti iz sostava RSFSR. Postanovlenie Verhovnogo Soveta Rossijskoj Federacii ot 6 fevralja 1992 goda №2292-4 [On the continuation of work on studying the legal basis of decisions of the Presidium of the Supreme Council of the USSR of 19 February 1954 and the Supreme Council of the USSR of 26 April 1954 on the removal of the Crimean region from the RSFSR. Postanovlenie of the Supreme Council of the Russian Federation of 6 February 1992 No. 2292-4]. URL: http://www.memory.gov.ua/publication/dokumenti-parlamentiv-ukraini-ta-rosii-1990-kh-rokiv-shchodo-statusu-krimu-ta-mista-seva [in Russian].
O statuse. (1993). O statuse goroda Sevastopolja. Postanovlenie Verhovnogo Soveta Rossijskoj Federacii ot 9 ijulja 1993 goda, № 5359-1 [On the status of the city of Sevastopol. Postanovlenie of the Supreme Council of the Russian Federation of January 9, 1993, No. 5359-1]. URL: http://www.memory.gov.ua/publication/dokumenti-parlamentiv-ukraini-ta-rosii-1990-kh-rokiv-shchodo-statusu-krimu-ta-mista-seva [in Russian].
Ob utverzhdenii. (1995). Ob utverzhdenii Strategicheskogo kursa Rossijskoj Federacii s gosudarstvami – uchastnikami Sodruzhestva Nezavisimyh Gosudarstv. Ukaz Prezidenta Rossijskoj Federacii ot 14 sentjabrja 1995 goda № 940 [On approval of the Strategic Course of the Russian Federation with the states – participants of the Commonwealth of Independent States. Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of September 14, 1995, No. 940]. URL: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_7780/2011a123b16a58aa919bb52261df7e3ee94ca6e3/ [in Russian].
Obrashhenie. (2014). Obrashhenie lidera Partii Regionov V. F. Yanukovicha k zhiteliam malorossiiskogo i novorossiiskogo kraev. 2 ark. U Careva znaishli lystіvki pro Putіna і pravila povedіnki pіd chas “zachystki” mіsta mirotvorcjami RF [The leaders of V. F. Yanukovich's Party of Regions spoke to residents of the Malorossian and Novorossian territories (2 pages). Carev published leaflets about Putin and the rules of conduct during the “secret” period of the RF peacekeeping forces.]. Prestupnosti NET. URL: https://news.pn/uk/criminal/104800 [in Russian].
Parlamentski sluрannya. (2003). Parlamentski sluрannya “Ukrainsko-rosiiski vidnosyny: suchasnyi stan ta perspektyvy”. Verhovna Rada Ukrainy. 22 zhovtnya 2003 roku [Parliamentary report “Ukrainian-Russian relations: current state and prospects”. Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. October 22, 2003]. URL: https://static.rada.gov.ua/zakon/skl4/par_sl/sl221003.htm [in Ukrainian].
Pashkov, M. (2017). Rosiiska informaciina ekspansiya: ukrainskyi placzdarm [Russian information expansion: Ukrainian placzdarm]. Informacijnyi byuleten centru Razumkova, 45, 3–12. [in Ukrainian].
Pecherskyi, A. (2022). Vse pochynalosya z Tuzly: koly rosiiski ZMI pochaly “voyuvaty” proty Ukrainy [It all started in Tuzla: when Russian media began to “fight” against Ukraine]. ArmiyaInform. URL: https://armyinform.com.ua/2022/05/26/vse-pochynalosya-z-tuzly-koly-rosijski-zmi-pochaly-voyuvaty-proty-ukrayiny/ [in Ukrainian].
Petrenko, V., & Novak, Ye. (2023). “Kolorovi revoliucyi”: sutnist, osnovni chynnyky ta harakterni rysy [“Color revolutions”: essence, basic principles and characteristic features]. Politychne zhyttya, 2, 18–23. [in Ukrainian].
Plokhy, S. (2023). The Russo-Ukrainian War: The Return of History. W. W. Norton & Company. [in English].
Politychnyi proces. (2016). Politychnyi proces v Avtonomniy Respublici Krym: osoblyvosti, superechnosti, prorahunky (1991 – 2014 rr.). Analitychna dopovid [Political process in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea: features, trends, calculations (1991 – 2014). Analytical report]. Kyiv: IPiEND im. I. F. Kurasa NAN Ukrainy. [in Ukrainian].
Polozhenie. (2009). Polozhenie o Vsemirnom koordinacionnom sovete rossijskih sootechestvennikov, prozhivajushhih za rubezhom. Utverzhdeno na Vsemirnom kongresse sootechestvennikov, prozhivajushhih za rubezhom. Moskva, 1–2 dekabrja 2009 g. [Agreement on the Supreme Coordination Council of Russian Socialist Industrialists Living Abroad. Approved by the Supreme Congress of Socialist Industrialists Living Abroad. Moscow, 1–2 December 2009]. MID Rossii. URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20131110102839/http:/www.mid.ru/ns-dgpch.nsf/a658d6341a624f7fc3257513004679f8/d9bfc5901340944cc3257689004a3637?OpenDocument [in Russian].
Popov, Ye. (2009). Ukraina kak geopoliticheskoe nedorazumenie [Ukraine as a geopolitical misunderstanding]. Stoletie. URL: http://www.stoletie.ru/politika/ukraina_kak_geopoliticheskoe_nedorazumenie_2009-02-25.html [in Russian].
Pro kilkist. (2001). Pro kilkist ta sklad naselennya Ukrainy za pidsumkamy Vseukrayinskoho perepysu naselennya 2001 roku [On the number and composition of the population of Ukraine according to the results of the All-Ukrainian Population Census of 2001]. Derzhavnyj komitet statystyky Ukrainy. URL: http://2001.ukrcensus.gov.ua/results/general/nationality/ [in Ukrainian].
Pro pravonastupnyctvo. (1991). Pro pravonastupnyctvo Ukrainy. Zakon Ukrainy vid 12.09.1991 № 1543-XII [For the legal succession of Ukraine. Law of Ukraine dated 12.09.1991 No. 1543-XII]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1543-12#Text [in Ukrainian].
Pro ratyfikaciyu. (2010). Pro ratyfikaciyu Uhody mizh Ukrainoiu ta Rosiiskoiu Federaciieiu z pytan perebuvannya Chornomorskoho flotu Rosiiskoyi Federaciy na terytoriy Ukrainy. Zakon Ukrainy vid 27 kvitnya 2010 roku № 2153-VI [On the ratification of the Agreement between Ukraine and the Russian Federation on the stationing of the Black Sea Fleet of the Russian Federation on the territory of Ukraine. Law of Ukraine dated April 27, 2010 No. 2153-VI]. URL : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2153-vi#Text [in Ukrainian].
Pro zayavu. (1993). Pro zayavu Prezydiy Verhovnoi Rady Ukrainy pro Postanovu Verhovnoi Rady Rosiiskoyi Federaciy vid 9 lypnia 1993 roku “Pro status mista Sevastopolia”. Postanova Prezydiy Verhovnoi Rady Ukrainy vid 9 lypnia 1993 roku [For the application of the Presidium of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine for the Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of the Russian Federation dated July 9, 1993 “On the status of the city of Sevastopol”. Resolution of the Presidium of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine dated July 9, 1993]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3375-12#Text [in Ukrainian].
Sauer, P. (2022). Russian Armed Volunteers Prepare for Action in Eastern Ukraine. The Moscow Times. URL: https:www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/02/10/russian-armed-volunteers-prepare-for-action-in-eastern-ukraine-a76331 [in English].
SBU. (2014). SBU zatrymala lidera “Doneckoyi respubliky” [SBU arrested the leader of the “Donetsk Republic”]. Espresso. URL: https://archive.ph/20140329134526/http://espreso.tv/new/2014/03/19/sbu_zatrymala_lidera_doneckoyi_respubliky - selection-443.0-443.43 [in Ukrainian].
Shveda, Yu. R. (2023). Agent vplyvu [Agent of influence]. Velyka ukrayinska encyklopediya. URL: https://vue.gov.ua/Agent vplyvu [in Ukrainian].
Sikora, B. (2002). Rosiiska ekonomichna ekspansiya v Ukraini [Russian economic expansion in Ukraine]. Universum, 7–8 (105–106). URL: https://universum.lviv.ua/magazines/universum/2002/3/exp.html [in Ukrainian].
Soldatenko, V. (2011). Donecko-Kryvorizka respublika. Istoriya separatystskoho mifu [Donetsk – Kryvyi Rih Republic. The history of the separatist myth]. Istorychna pravda. URL: https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2011/02/11/23624/ [in Ukrainian].
Soobshhenie. (1994). Soobshhenie oblasnoj komissii po soveshhatelnomu oprosu grazhdan oblasti ot 1 aprelja 1994 g. [Report of the regional commission on the advisory survey of citizens of the region dated April 1, 1994]. Donbass. URL: https://ua-reporter.com/news/27-let-referendumu-v-donbasse-po-voprosu-dvuyazychiya-i-soyuza-s-rossiey [in Russian].
Stenograma # 63. (1995). Zasidannya Verxovnoyi Rady` Ukrayiny` 25 travnya 1995 r. S. 1-98. URL : https://www.rada.gov.ua/meeting/stenogr/print/3672.html
Stenogramma Severodoneckogo s#ezda 28 nojabrja 2004 goda. (2009). Vostochnyj variant. URL: https://v-variant.com.ua/articles/81128-stenogramma-severodoneckogo-sezda-28-noyabrya-2004-goda.html [in Russian].
Tkachenko, V. M. (2017). Ukraina: “chas viyny i chas myru” [Ukraine: “time of war and time of peace”]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian historical journal, 1, 135–156. [in Ukrainian].
Tretiakova, M. (2014). Referendum o federalizacii Donbassa: 20 let borby [Referendum on federalization of Donbass: 20 years of struggle]. Aktualnye komentarii. URL: https://actualcomment.ru/referendum-o-federalizatsii-donbassa-20-let-borby.html [in Russian].
Tuzla. (2003). Tuzla: z kym mayemo spravu? Tekst obsuzhdeniya tuzlynskogo krizisa v programme “Svoboda slova” [Tuzla: Who are we dealing with? Text of the discussion of the Tuzla crisis in the program “Freedom of Speech”]. Den. URL: https://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/panorama-dnya/tuzla-z-kim-maiemo-spravu [in Ukrainian].
Uhoda. (2010). Uhoda mizh Ukrayinoyu i Rosijs`koyu Federaciyeyu z py`tan` perebuvannya Chornomorskoho flotu Rosiiskoyi Federaciy na terytoriy Ukrainy vid 21 kvitnya 2010 roku (nabrala chynnosti 14.05.2010) [Agreement between Ukraine and the Russian Federation on the relocation of the Black Sea Fleet of the Russian Federation to the territory of Ukraine dated April 21, 2010 (entered into force on May 14, 2010)]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/643_359#Text [in Ukrainian].
V Odesi. (2004). V Odesi lunaiut zaklyky do stvorennya na terytoriyi oblasti samovryaduvannya “Novorosijskyi krai” [In Odessa, there are calls for the creation of a self-governing region “Novorossiysk Krai” on the territory of the region]. UNIAN. URL : https://press.unian.ua/press/964594-v-odesi-lunayut-zakliki-do-stvorennya-na-teritoriji-oblasti-samovryaduvannya-novorosiyskiy-kray.html [in Russian].
V sluchae. (2018). V sluchae zahvata Tuzly, ukrainskaja armija byla gotova otkryt ogon [In case of Tuzla capture, the Ukrainian army was ready to open fire]. Vіdeo YouTube. Fakty ICTV. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEI1DUKusUU [in Russian].
V svjazi. (1995). V svjazi s reshenijami Verhovnogo Soveta Ukrainy po Krymu. Postanovlenie Gosudarstvennoj Dumy Federalnogo Sobranija Rossiiskoj Federacii ot 22 marta 1995 goda [In connection with the decisions of the Supreme Council of Ukraine on Crimea. Resolution of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation of March 22, 1995]. URL : http://sevkrimrus. narod.ru/ZAKON/1995ref.htm#2 [in Russian].
Vladimirov, V. (2021). Zabytyi ultimatum [The Ultimate Forgotten]. Sovershenno sekretno. URL: https://www.sovsekretno.ru/articles/istoriya/zabytyy-ultimatum/ [in Russian].
Vybory-2004. (2004). Vybory-2004: Vlacti Doneckoj oblasti predlozhili provesti referendum ob avtonomki [Elections 2004: Donetsk regional authorities propose holding a referendum on autonomous region]. Lugansk.info. URL: http://news.lugansk.info/lugansk/2004_2/000415.shtml [in Russian].
Vystuplenie. (2008). Vystuplenie V. Putina na zasedanii soveta “Rossija – NATO” v ramkah sammita NATO. Stenogramma (Buharest, 4 aprelja 2008 g.) [Speech by V. Putin at the meeting of the Russia-NATO Council within the framework of the NATO summit. Transcript (Bucharest, April 4, 2008)]. URL: https://aillarionov.livejournal.com/723745.html [in Russian].
Yakubova, L. (2022). Ontolohiia rashyzmu: Ukraina yak alter ego Rosii [Ontology of rashizm: Ukraine as an alter ego of Russia]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian historical journal, 4, 78–92. [in Ukrainian].
Yurchenko, O. (2020). Udar po krymskyh portah: Rosiya zabrala zbory za prohid Kerch-Yenikalskym kanalom [Strike on the Crimean gates: Russia seizes the Kerch-Yenikalskyi Canal pass]. Krym. Realiyi. URL: https://ua.krymr.com/a/rosiya-vdaryla-po-krymskym-portam/30425044.html [in Ukrainian].
Zajavlenie. (1992). Zajavlenie Verhovnogo Soveta RSFSR Verhovnomu Sovetu Ukrainy ot 22 maja 1992 goda [Statement of the Supreme Council of the RSFSR to the Supreme Council of Ukraine, May 22, 1992]. URL: http://www.memory.gov.ua/publication/dokumenti-parlamentiv-ukraini-ta-rosii-1990-kh-rokiv-shchodo-statusu-krimu-ta-mista-seva [in Russian].
Zevelev, I. (2016). The Russian World in Moscow’s Strategy. CSIS. Center for Strategic & International Studies. URL: https://www.csis.org/analysis/russian-world-moscows-strategy [in English].
Zhirohov, M. (2020). Nachalo “gibridnoj vojny”: kak Ukraina otstojala ostrov Tuzla [The Beginning of the “Hybrid War”: How Ukraine Defended Tuzla Island]. Flot2017. URL: https://flot2017.com/nachalo-gibridnoj-vojny-kak-ukraina-otstoyala-ostrov-tuzla/ [in Russian].
Zhulynskyi, M. (2019). Gumanitarna ekspansiya Rosiyi: istoriya ta suchasnist [Humanitarian expansion of Russia: history and present]. Visnyk Nacionalnoi Academii Nauk, 5, 84–98. [in Ukrainian].
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.