THE UKRAINIAN QUESTION IN THE FOREIGN POLICY OF THE SECOND POLISH REPUBLIC AT THE TURN OF 1938 – 1939

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.30.299910

Keywords:

Carpatho-Ukraine, Ukrainian issue, Second Polish Republic, international relations, Munich conference

Abstract

The purpose of the proposed article is to elucidate the role and place of the Ukrainian issue in the foreign policy of the Second Polish Republic at the turn of 1938  1939, in particular its relations with Germany, the USSR, and Romania. The study of Poland’s foreign policy in 1938  1939 is central to understanding the dynamics of international processes in East-Central Europe on the eve of World War II. After all, the fate of peace on the continent ultimately hinged upon Warsaw’s relations with Berlin, Moscow, London, and Paris. The background of these relations was the Ukrainian issue, which entered a new stage of its internationalization in the wake of the “Czechoslovak crisis” and the emergence of Carpatho-Ukraine as a factor in international politics. The formation of Ukrainian autonomy south of the Carpathians in October of 1938 exposed the Ukrainian issue on a global scale as the largest unresolved national issue in interwar Europe. In 1938 – 1939, Subcarpathian Rus’/Carpatho-Ukraine turned into a geopolitical frontier, a zone of conflict of interests of key European players (Germany, Hungary, Poland, Romania, the USSR, Great Britain, France, Italy). The research methodology is based on the approach of “histoire croisée”, “entangled history” and “connected history”, as subspecies of global history. This approach, in our opinion, serves as an effective means of integrating the Ukrainian history into a global historical context, giving the national metanarrative features of inclusiveness. The scientific novelty consists in the fact that the author tried, based on a wide range of published and unpublished archival documents, to comprehensively reveal the role of the Ukrainian issue in the foreign policy of the Second Polish Republic against the background of international relations during the turning point in the history of interwar Europe. The Conclusions. It has been established that the post-Munich period of international relations was marked by the actualization of the Ukrainian issue in European politics, the impetus for which gave the formation of Carpathian Ukraine as an autonomous unit within the Second Czecho-Slovak Republic. At the turn of 1938  1939, the Ukrainian issue became a central topic on the agenda of the Polish diplomacy, which was an important factor in its relations with Germany, the USSR, Romania, and Czecho-Slovakia. The balance of power in the east of the continent, the state of relations between them, and ultimately the fate of peace and war in Europe depended largely on the attitude of the key subjects of international relations to the Ukrainian issue. The period of 1938  1939 was marked by the active rapprochement of Poland and Germany against the background of the dismemberment of Czecho-Slovakia and Berlin’s determined efforts to draw Warsaw into its orbit of influence in order to form a military and political alliance against the USSR. In the bilateral German-Polish negotiations, the Ukrainian issue appeared as a certain “bait” and “bargaining chip” that the Nazis actively traded, hoping to attract Poland to their side to realize their long-term goals in the East. Despite the existence of a pro-German wing among the Polish ruling camp, which advocated cooperation with the Third Reich in solving the Ukrainian issue and a joint campaign against the USSR in the spirit of the concept of Prometheism, the Polish diplomacy led by Józef Beck at the beginning of 1939 rejected German demands and gradually took a course towards resumption of cooperation with Western democracies – Great Britain and France. At the same time, at least until the end of March 1939, there was still room for the German-Polish negotiations, in which the Ukrainian issue ceased to play a leading role.

References

Archiwum Akt Nowych – AAN [Archives of New Acts]

Batowski, H. (1962). Kryzys dyplomatyczny w Europie. Jeseń 1938 – wiosna 1939 [A Diplomatic Crisis in Europe. Autumn 1938]. Warszawa. [in Polish]

Batowski, H. (1973). Zrada monachijska. Sprawa Czechoslowacji i dyplomacia europejska w roku 1938 [The Monach Betrayal. The Question of Czechoslovakia and European Diplomacy in the Year of 1938]. Poznań. [in Polish]

Batowski, H. (2008). Między dwiema wojnami 1919 – 1939. Zarys historii dyplomatycznej [Between the Two Wars 1919 – 1939. An Account on the History of Diplomacy]. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. [in Polish]

Budurovych, B. (1958). The Ukrainian Problem in International Politics, October 1938 to March 1939. Canadian Slavonic Papers / Revue Canadienne des Slavistes, 3, 59–75. [in English]

Cienciala, A. (1999). The Munich Crisis of 1938: Plans and strategy in Warsaw in the Context of the Western Appeasement of Germany. The Munich Crisis, 1938. Prelude to World War II, (pp. 48–81). Red. I. Lukes, E. Goldstein. London – Portland. [in English]

Dąbrowski, D. (2007). Rzeczpospolita Polska wobec kwestii Rusi Zakarpackiej (Podkarpackiej), 1938 – 1939 [The Polish Republic on the Issue of Transcarpathian (Subcarpathian) Rus’, 1938 – 1939]. Toruń. [in Polish]

DBFP. (1950). Documents on British Foreign Policy 1919 – 1939. Third series. Vol. III. 1938 – 1939. London. [in English]

DBFP. (1953). Documents on British Foreign Policy 1919 – 1939. Third series. Vol. II. 1938. London. [in English]

DIMK. (1970). Diplomáciai iratok Magyarország külpolitikájához, 1936 – 1945 [Diplomatic Documents on Hungary’s Foreign Policy, 1936 – 1945]. Vol. ІІІ. Magyarország külpolitikája, 1938 – 1939 [Hungary’s foreign policy, 1938 – 1939]. M. Ádám. Budapest. [in Hungarian]

DTJS. (1938, 1939). Diariusz i teki Jana Szembeka (1935 – 1945). [The Diary and Papers of Jan Szembek] (1972). T. 4: Diariusz i dokumentacja za rok 1938; Diariusz i dokumentacja za rok 1939 [Diary and documents for the year of 1938; Diary and documents for the year of 1939]. Oprac. Jozef Zaranski. London: Polish Research Centre: The Polish Institute and Sikorski Museum. [in Polish]

God krizisa. (1990). God krizisa, 1938 – 1939: Dokumenty i materialy [The Year of Crisis 1938 – 1939: Documents and Materials]. T. 1 (29 sentyabrya 1938 g. – 31 maya 1939 g.). Moskva: Politizdat. [in Russian]

Hai-Nyzhnyk, P. (2018). Karpatska Ukraina (Pidkarpatska Rus) 1938 – 1939 rr. yak odna iz “rozminnykh monet” Miunkhenskoho dohovoru [Carpatho-Ukraine (Subcarpathian Rus’) 1938 – 1939 as One of the Bargaining Chips of the Munich Agreement]. Hileia. Istorychni nauky – Hileia. Historical Sciences, 139, 48–56. [in Ukrainian]

Hetmanchuk, M. (2003). Borotba Karpatskoi Ukrainy za nezalezhnist v konteksti radiansko-polskykh vidnosyn (1938 – berezen 1939 rr.) [Carpatho-Ukraine’s Fight for Independence in the Context of the Soviet-Polish Relations (1938 – March 1939)]. Visnyk Natsionalnoho universytetu “Lvivska politekhnika” – Bulletin of the National University “Lviv Polytechnic”, 474: Derzhava ta armiia [The state and the army], 46–55. [in Ukrainian]

Hetmanchuk, M. (2008). Mizh Moskvoiu ta Varshavoiu. Ukrainske pytannia v radiansko-polskykh vidnosynakh mizhvoiennoho periodu (1918 – 1939 rr.) [Between Moscow and Warsaw. The Ukrainian Issue in the Soviet-Polish Relations of the Interwar Period (1918 – 1939]. Lviv: Vydavnytstvo Natsionalnoho universytetu “Lvivska politekhnika”. [in Ukrainian]

Hory, A. (2017). “Martwa placówka”. Wspomnienia i korespondencja posła Królestwa Węgier w Warszawie 1935 – 1939 [“A Dead Outpost”. Memoirs and Correspondence of Hungary’s Ambassador to Warszaw 1935 – 1939]. Przedmowa Pál Pritz, posłowie Marek Kornat, IPN, Urząd do Spraw Kombatantów i Osób Represjonowanych, Węgierski Instytut Kultury, Węgierskie Archiwum Narodowe, Warszawa. [in Polish]

Jarnecki, M. & Kołakowski, P. (2017). “Ukraiński Piemont”. Ruś Zakarpacka w okresie autonomii 1938 – 1939 [“Ukrainian Piedmont”. Transcarpathian Rus’ in the Period of Autonomy 1938 – 1939]. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Oficyna Wydawnicza RYTM. [in Polish]

Kornat, M. & Wołos, M. (2021). Józef Beck. Biografia [Józef Beck. Biography]. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. [in Polish]

Kornat, M. (2007). Polityka rownowagi. 1934 – 1939: Polska między Wschodem a Zachodem [Balance-of-Forces Policy, 1934 – 1939: Poland between East and West]. Krakow: Wyd-wo Arcana. [in Polish]

Kornat, M. (2012). Polityka zagraniczna Polski 1938 – 1939. Cztery decyzje Józefa Becka [Poland’s Foriegn Policy 1938 – 1939. Józef Beck’s Four Decisions]. Muzeum II Wojny Światowej w Gdańsku. Gdańsk: Wydawnictwo Oskar. [in Polish]

Łubieński, M. (2012). Refleksje i reminiscencje [Reflections and Reminiscences]. Wstęp i opracowanie M. Kornat. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe. [in Polish]

Pahiria, O. (2017). “Ukrainskyi Piemont u Karpatakh”: ukrainske pytannia v zakhidnomu publichnomu dyskursi pid chas chekhoslovatskoi kryzy 1938 – 1939 rr. [“The Ukrainian Piedmont in the Carpathians”: the Ukrainian Question in the Western Political Discourse During the Czechoslovakian Crisis of 1938 – 1939]. Ukraina: kulturna spadshchyna, natsionalna svidomist, derzhavnist – Ukraine: cultural heritage, national consciousness, statist, 30, 113–135. [in Ukrainian]

Pilarski, S. (2008). Polskie ugrupowania polityczne wobec Czechosłowacji 1938 – 1939 [Polish Politic Groups on Czechoslovakia in 1938 – 1939]. Oddział w Łodzi Instytut Pamięci Narodowej. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Neriton. [in Polish]

Pisuliński, J. (2008). Kwestia ukraińska w polskiej polityce zagranicznej w drugiej połowie lat trzydziestych XX wieku [The Ukrainian Issue in Polish Foreign Policy in the Second Half of the 1930s]. Historia – Polityka – Społeczeństwo. Księga jubileuszowa dedykowana Profesorowi Henrykowi Cimkowi, (pp. 115–122). Rzeszów. [in Polish]

Poland. (1976). Poland and the coming of the Second World War: the diplomatic papers of A. J. Drexel Biddle, Jr., United States Ambassador to Poland, 1937 – 1939. Ohio State University Press. [in English]

Polska a Monachium. (1967). Polska a Monachium [Poland and Munich]. Warszawa. [in Polish]

Polskie dokumenty. (2005). Polskie dokumenty dyplomatyczne 1939 styczeń – sierpień [Polish Diplomatic Papers January – August of 1939]. Red. Stanisław Żerko; współpr. Piotr Długołęcki. Warszawa: Polski Instytut Spraw Międzynarodowych. [in Polish]

Polskie dokumenty. (2007). Polskie dokumenty dyplomatyczne 1938 [Polish Diplomatic Papers 1938]. (PDD). Red. Marek Kornat; współpr. Piotr Długołęcki, Maria Konopka-Wichrowska, Marta Przyłuska. Warszawa: Polski Instytut Spraw Międzynarodowych. [in Polish]

Rak, K. (2019). Polska – niespełniony sojusznik Hitlera [Poland – Hitler’s Unfulfilled Ally]. Warszawa: Bellona. [in Polish]

Shkandrij, M. (2015). Radio Vienna: Broadcasts by the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists, 1938 – 1939. Kyiv-Mohyla Humanities Journal, 2, 121–136. [in English]

Shvahuliak, M. (2000). Ukrainske pytannia v mizhnarodnykh politychnykh kryzakh peredodnia Druhoi svitovoi viiny (1938 – 1939) [The Ukrainian Issue in the International Political Crisis on WWII Eve (1938 – 1939)]. Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu. Seriia istorychna – Bulletin of Lviv University. The historical series, 35–36, 296–320. [in Ukrainian]

Stanislawska, S. (1962). Wielka i mała polityka Jósefa Becka: marzec – maj 1938 [Jósef Beck’s Great and Small Policy: March – May of 1938]. Warszawa. [in Polish]

Stosunki polsko-czechosłowackie. (2006). Stosunki polsko-czechosłowackie 1932-1939 w relacjach dyplomatów II Rzeczypospolitej [Polish-Czechoslovak Relations of 1932-1939 in the Accounts of Diplomats of the Second Polish Republic]. Opracowal Nowinowski S. M. Łódź. [in Polish]

Sviderska, N. (2001a). Ukrainske pytannia naperedodni Druhoi svitovoi viiny (veresen 1938 – veresen 1939 rr.) [The Ukrainian Issue on the Eve of WWII (September 1938 – September 1939]. (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Lviv. [in Ukrainian]

Sviderska, N. (2001b). Radianskyi Soiuz u dyplomatychnii intryzi navkolo Karpatskoi Ukrainy [The Soviet Union in the Diplomatic Intrigue around Carpatho-Ukraine]. Naukovi zapysky Ternopilskoho derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Volodymyra Hnatiuka. Seriia: Istoriia – Scientific notes of Ternopil State Pedagogical University named after Volodymyr Hnatyuk. Series: History, 12, 121–126. [in Ukrainian]

Trofymovych, L. & Trofymovych, V. (2013). Nebezpechne supernytstvo… Ukrainske pytannia v zovnishnii politytsi Polshchi ta Radianskoho Soiuzu. 1938 – 1939 rr [The Dangerous Rivalry... The Ukrainian Question in the Foreign Policies of Poland and the Soviet Union. 1938 – 1939]. Rivne, Volynski oberehy. [in Ukrainian]

Trofymovych, L. & Trofymovych, V. (2018). Pytannia Pidkarpatskoi Rusi v zovnishnopolitychnykh rozrakhunkakh Polshchi (zhovten 1938 – berezen 1939 r.) [The Issue of Subcarpathian Rus’ in Poland’s Foreign Policy Calculations (October 1938 – March 1939)]. Rusyn, 52, 309–328. [in Ukrainian]

Trofymovych, L. & Trofymovych, V. (2019). Karpatoukrainskyi aspekt zovnishnoi polityky yevropeiskykh krain u period chekhoslovatskoi kryzy (1938 – 1939 rr.) [The Carpatho-Ukrainian Aspect of the Foreign Policy of European Countries During the Czechoslovak crisis (1938 – 1939)]. Rusyn, 57, 251–270. [in Ukrainian]

Vidnianskyi, S. (2019). Karpatska Ukraina yak etap ukrainskoho derzhavotvorennia [Carpatho-Ukraine as a Stage of Ukrainian State-Building]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian historical journal, 2, 67–93. [in Ukrainian]

Vidnianskyi, S., Hrytsiuk, V. & Lysenko, О. (2019). Pochatok “Druhoi imperialistychnoi viiny” ta “ukrainske pytannia”: deiaki dyplomatychni, politychni, voienni aspekty [Beginning of the “Second Imperialistic War” and the “Ukrainian Question”: Certain Diplomatic, Political and Military Aspects]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian historical journal, 5, 4–24. [in Ukrainian]

Żerko, S. (2020). Stosunki polsko-niemieckie 1938 – 1939 [Polish-German Relations in 1938 – 1939]. Wyd. II poprawione. Seria: Studium Niemcoznawcze Instytutu Zachodniego nr 96. Instytut Zachodni. Poznań. [in Polish]

Zięba, А. (2010). Lobbing dla Ukrainy w Europie międzywojennej. Ukraińskie Biuro Prasowe w Londynie oraz jego konkurenci polityczni (do roku 1932) [The Lobbying for Ukraine in Interwar Europe. The Ukrainian Press Bureau in London and its Political Rivals (until 1932)]. Kraków: Księgarnia Akademicka. [in Polish]

Zlepko, D. (1994). Ukrainske pytannia u 1938 – 1939 rokakh i Tretii Raikh [The Ukrainian Issue in 1938 – 1939 and the Third Reich]. Zapysky Naukovoho tovarystva im. Shevchenka. Pratsi istoryko-filosofskoi sektsii – Notes of the Shevchenko Scientific Society. Works of the historical and philosophical section, 228, 249–308). [in Ukrainian]

Downloads

Published

2024-03-28

Issue

Section

Articles