DAILY LIFE OF THE POPULATION OF SOVIET TRANSCARPATIA IN THE DOCUMENTS OF THE USA CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY (SECOND HALF OF THE 1940s – EARLY 1950s)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.29.292939Abstract
The purpose of the study is to investigate the peculiarities of the US intelligence's vision of the processes of sovietization in Transcarpathia and their impact on the daily life of the region's residents, based on the declassified CIA materials. The research methodology is based on the principles of historicism, scientificity, and objectivity that are fundamental for historians. It was also necessary to apply historical and systemic, historical and comparative methods of historical science, which allowed, first of all, to trace the specifics of the formation of images of the history of Transcarpathia in the assessment of CIA specialists in the context of the initial stage of the “Cold War”. The scientific novelty of the study consists in an effort to carry out a balanced and comprehensive analysis of the vision of the US intelligence on various aspects of the daily life of Soviet Transcarpathia population (processes of collectivization, a daily life of the population of the region's towns, activities of the authorities, etc.). The authors elucidated the content and a factual validity of these processes, showed their orientation and the main objects and lines of analysis. The set of documents analysed in the article is informative enough to fulfill the research objectives. The Conclusion. Despite the fact that the USSR was a strategic adversary of the USA during the Cold War, the information of the CIA specialists regarding the life of the population of Transcarpathia as a part of it is not one-sided in the framework of a possible “two-colour” analysis (“black and white”). In a number of relevant documents, sympathy for the population of the region is palpable, rather difficult conditions of its economic, political and cultural life in the first post-war years, a strict management style of the state and party leadership of Transcarpathia, a significant role of power structures, etc. have been emphasized. It is also important to recognize the Ukrainianness of the population of Transcarpathia, despite the presence of “mental” and “cultural” barriers among local residents and visitors, including those from the eastern regions of Ukraine.
Keywords: everyday life, the USSR, the Ukrainian SSR, Transcarpathian region, the CIA, intelligence, information.
References
AERODYNAMIC VOL. 25 (OPERATIONS)_0032 NO. PAGES 2. Comments on Release from Prison of Metropolitan Yosif Slipyy. 4 March 1963/. URL: https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/AERODYNAMIC%20%20%20VOL.%2025%20%20%28OPERATIONS%29_0032.pdf). [in English]
CIA-RDP80-00809A000600040072-8. Past and prezent developments concerning Carpatho-Ruthenia. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP80-00809A000600040072-8.pdf. [in English]
CIA-RDP80-00810A000600490008-4. Miscellaneous Information on the City of Uzhgorod and Surrounding Area. DATE DISTR, 14 April 1953. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP80-00810A000600490008-4.pdf. [in English]
CIA-RDP82-00046R000100230004-1. Collectivisation in Carpatho-Ukraine. DATE DISTR, 28 August 1953. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00046R000100230004-1.pdf. [in English]
CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030017-8. Standard of living in the Carpathian oblast 18 aug 53. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030017-8.pdf. [in English]
CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030018-7. Prices (in rubles) of Consumer goods in Mucachevo, Carpathian oblast. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030018-7.pdf. [in English]
CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030019-6. Approximate prices (in rubles) of meals and liquor (1950-1952) in Mukachevo. URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00046R000200030019-6.pdf. [in English]
Haliv, M. & Sviontyk, O. (2023). Ukrainian Historians on “Historiographic Front” of the Russian-Ukrainian War (review on the book: TURNING POINT: Russia's War against Ukraine in the Time Layers and Spaces of the Past. Dialogues with Historians. Editor-in-Chief Valeriy Smoliy; editor: Hennadiy Boriak, Oleksiy Yas, Svitlana Blaschuk. Kyiv: National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. Institute of History of Ukraine, 2023. Book 3. 844 pp.; ill.). Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk – East European Historical Bulletin, 28, 262–269. doi: https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.28.287563. [in English]
Hlahola, V. (2017). Yak rozvidka SSHA bachyla sotsial'ne zhyttya Uzhhoroda v 1953 rotsi (Dokumenty) [How US intelligence saw the social life of Uzhhorod in 1953 (Documents)]. URL: http://prozak.info/Suspil-stvo/YAk-rozvidka-SSHA-bachila-social-ne-zhittya-Uzhgoroda-v-1953-roci-DOKUMENTI. [in Ukrainian]
Ilnytskyi, V. & Holovko, V. (2021). History of an everyday life of the western ukrainian peasantry (review of the monograph: Starka V.V. Everyday Life of the Western Ukrainian Peasantry under the Conditions of Social Transformations in 1939 – 1953. Ternopil: Osadtsa Yu.V., 2019. 550 p.). Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk – East European Historical Bulletin, 18, 265–269. doi: 10.24919/2519-058X.18.226543. [in English]
Kornovenko, S. & Shamrai, O. (2023). Everyday life of the post-war ukrainian village (peer-review of the monograph: Marchenko V.A., Nikiliev O.F. Everyday Life of a Post-War Ukrainian Village (the mid-1940 s – the first half of the 1950 s). Dnipro: Lira, 2022. 180 p.). Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk – East European Historical Bulletin, 27, 277–283. doi: 10.24919/2519-058X.27.281525. [in English]
Kuryshko, Diana. (2017). Arkhivy TsRU: khto i yak shpyhuvav za ukrayintsyamy [CIA archives: who spied on Ukrainians and how]. URL: https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/news-38815977. [in Ukrainian]
Lendyel, R. (2017). Iz arkhivu TsRU: NKVS hotuvalo vbyvstvo yepyskopa Romzhi na nayvyshchomu rivni (Dokument) [From the CIA archive: the NKVD prepared the assassination of Bishop Romzhi at the highest level (Document)]. URL: http://www.mukachevo.net/ua/news/view/186046. [in Ukrainian]
Literati, Tetyana. (2017). Uzhhorod v arkhivakh TsRU: amerykantsi vzhe u 50-kh znaly, de viys'kovi ob'yekty ta skil'kokh koriv shchodnya rizhut' na m'yasokombinati. [Uzhhorod in the archives of the CIA: already in the 50s, the Americans knew where the military facilities were and how many cows were slaughtered at the meat processing plant every dayin]. URL: https://prozahid.com/content-42077-html/. [in Ukrainian]
Marchuk, I. & Bukhalo, O. (2022). Yakym TsRU bachylo Rivne 70 rokiv tomu. Istoryk opratsyuvav dani rozsekrechenykh dokumentiv [How the CIA saw Rivne 70 years ago. The historian processed the data of declassified documents]. URL: https://suspilne.media/343400-akim-cru-bacilo-rivne-70-rokiv-tomu-istorik-opracuvav-dani-rozsekrecenih-dokumentiv/. [in Ukrainian]
Mishchanyn, V. (2000). Ahrarna polityka na Zakarpatti (1944 – 1950 rr.) [Agrarian policy in Transcarpathia (1944 – 1950)]. Uzhhorod: Vydavnytstvo “Zakarpattya”. [in Ukrainian].
Mishchanyn, V. (2018). Radyanizatsiya Zakarpattya 1944 – 1950 rr. [Sovietization of Transcarpathia, 1944 – 1950]. Uzhhorod: RIK-U, 644 s. [in Ukrainian].
Narodne. (1969). Narodne hospodarstvo radyans'koho Zakarpattya. Statystychnyy zbirnyk [National economy of Soviet Transcarpathia. Statistical collection]Uzhhorod: Karpaty. [in Ukrainian]
Narodne. (1987). Narodne hospodarstvo Zakarpat·s'koyi oblasti. Statystychnyy zbirnyk [National economy of Zakarpattia region. (1987). Statistical collection]. Uzhhorod: Karpaty. [in Ukrainian]
Popp, R. & Kantor, N. (2023). Everyday Life of Intelligentsia of the Western Region of Ukraine in 1944 – 1953. Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk – East European Historical Bulletin, 21, 162–171. doi: 10.24919/2519-058X.21.246920. [in English]
Putin=Stalin. (2016). Putin=Stalin. Cherez “Deklyaratsiyu” OUN 1945 roku Rosiya zakryla dostup do vs'oho onlayn-arkhivu ukrayins'koho vyzvol'noho rukhu [Putin=Stalin. Due to the “Declaration” of the OUN of 1945, Russia closed access to the entire online archive of the Ukrainian liberation movement]. URL: https://novynarnia.com/2016/08/13/putin-stalin-cherez-deklyaratsiyu-oun-1945-roku-rosiya-zakrila-dostup-do-vsogo-onlayn-arhivu-ukrayinskogo-vizvolnogo-ruhu/. [in Ukrainian]
Rozsekrecheni. (2017). Rozsekrecheni arkhivy TsRU: u Mukachevi pislya viyny nemaye v'yaznytsi, vysoki tsiny ta potuzhnyy aerodrom (foto) [Declassified archives of the CIA: in Mukachevo after the war there is no prison, high prices and a powerful airfield (photo)]. URL: http://www.mukachevo.net/ua/news/view/185759. [in Ukrainian]
Rozsekrecheni. (2020). Rozsekrecheni arkhivy TsRU pro Zakarpattya: z choho pochalasya kolektyvizatsiya v oblasti (foto, dokumenty) [Declassified CIA archives about Transcarpathia: what started collectivization in the region (photos, documents)]. URL: https://goloskarpat.info/analytics/5e38596b7874f/?fbclid=IwAR35fOPEGE_h_LAK20ioNbI-qnJFEjo5sGY6uZzdoFuA6rirWg89YXr5hHY. [in Ukrainian]
Saliy, Yu. (2017). Kyiv 1950-kh rokiv u rozsekrechenykh dokumentakh TsRU [Kyiv in the 1950s in declassified CIA documents]. URL: https://hmarochos.kiev.ua/2017/01/23/kiyiv-1950-h-rokiv-u-rozsekrechenih-dokumentah-tsru/. [in Ukrainian]
Sedov, A. (2020). Ukrainskiye SMI: doklad TsRU SShA o prestupleniyakh Bandery pridumali v Moskve [Ukrainian media: US CIA report on Bandera’s crimes invented in Moscow]. URL: https://eadaily.com/ru/news/2020/01/24/ukrainskie-smi-doklad-cru-sshao-prestupleniyah-bandery-pridumali-v-moskve. [in Russian]
Shcho znala. (2017). Shcho znala rozvidka SSHA pro viys'kovyy potentsial Uzhhoroda v pislyavoyennyy period [What did US intelligence know about the military potential of Uzhhorod in the post-war period]. URL: http://prozak.info/IIstoriya/SCHo-znala-rozvidka-SSHA-pro-vijs-kovij-potencial-Uzhgoroda-v-pislyavoennij-period. [in Ukrainian]
Shurkhalo, D. (2017). Traplyayut'sya prosto unikal'ni rechi! – ukrayins'ki doslidnyky pro arkhiv TsRU [Just unique things happen! – Ukrainian researchers about the CIA archive]. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/28244827.html. [in Ukrainian]
Sudoplatov, P. (1998). Speczoperaczii. Lubyanka i Kreml' 1930 – 1950 gody [Special operations. Lubyanka and the Kremlin 1930 – 1950]. Moskva: OLMA-PRESS. [in Russian]
Telvak, V. & Ilnytskyi, V. (2023). A year of existential war in analytical reflections of the Warsaw centre for eastern studies. Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk – East European Historical Bulletin, 27, 249–258. doi: https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.27.281552. [in English].
Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv hromadskykh obiednan Ukrainy [Central State Archive of Public Associations of Ukraine – CSAPAU]
Tserkvy. (2018). Tserkvy v radyans'komu Zakarpatti u zvitakh TsRU: peresliduvannya svyashchenykiv ta kluby v khramakh (foto) [Churches in Soviet Transcarpathia in CIA reports: persecution of priests and clubs in churches (photo)]. URL: https://risu.ua/cerkvi-v-radyanskomu-zakarpatti-u-zvitah-cru-peresliduvannya-svyashchenikiv-ta-klubi-v-hramah-foto_n89049. [in Ukrainian]
TsRU oprylyudnylo. (2017). TsRU oprylyudnylo dani pro povoyenne Zakarpattia [The CIA released data on post-war Transcarpathia]. URL: https://zaholovok.com.ua/tsru-oprilyudnilo-dani-pro-povojenne-zakarpattya. [in Ukrainian]
TsRU pokazalo. (2020). TsRU pokazalo dokumenty o Bandere – agente Gitlera “Konsule 2” [The CIA showed documents about Bandera – Hitler’s agent “Consul 2”]. URL: https://eadaily.com/ru/news/2020/01/24/cru-pokazalo-dokumenty-o-bandere-agente-gitlera-konsule-2. [in Russian]
TsRU rozsekretylo arkhivy. (2017). TsRU rozsekretylo arkhivy: bil'she 11 tysyach dokumentiv – pro Ukrayinu [The CIA declassified the archives: more than 11 thousand documents – about Ukraine]. URL: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-society/2159068-cru-rozsekretilo-arhivi-bilse-11-tisac-dokumentiv-pro-ukrainu.html. [in Ukrainian]
TsRU rozsekretylo. (2017). TsRU rozsekretylo mayzhe mil'yon istorychnykh dokumentiv. Chymalo ye pro Ukrayinu [The CIA declassified nearly a million historical documents. There is a lot about Ukraine]. URL: https://www.istpravda.com.ua/short/2017/01/19/149475/. [in Ukrainian]
TsRU vyklalo. (2017). TsRU vyklalo onlayn arkhivy do seredyny 90-kh rokiv. (2017). Chytayemo pro Ukrayinu [The CIA put the archives online until the mid-1990s. We read about Ukraine]. URL: https://novynarnia.com/2017/01/18/tsru-viklalo-onlayn-arhivi-do-seredini-90-h-rokiv-chitayemo-pro-ukrayinu/. [in Ukrainian]
Tyshchuk, O. (2017). Sekretni arkhivy TsRU pro Ukrayinu. Pol's'kyy stsenariy ta bunt proty KDB [Secret archives of the CIA about Ukraine. The Polish scenario and the rebellion against the KGB]. URL: http://fakty.ictv.ua/ua/ukraine/20170124-sekretni-arhivy-tsru-pro-ukrayinu-polskyj-stsenarij-ta-bunt-proty-kdb/. [in Ukrainian]
U zviti. (2017). U zviti 1957 roku TsRU nazyvalo Cherkashchynu antyradyans'koyu zonoyu [In a 1957 report, the CIA called Cherkasy an anti-Soviet zone. Ukrainian]. URL: https://procherk.info/news/7-cherkassy/49932-u-zviti-1957-roku-tsru-nazivalo-cherkaschinu-antiradjanskoju-zonoju. [in Ukrainian]
Vus, O. (2017). TsRU rozsekretylo ponad 10 tysyach dokumentiv pro Ukrayinu [The CIA declassified more than 10,000 documents about Ukraine]. URL: https://politics.segodnya.ua/ua/politics/cru-rassekretilo-bolee-10-tysyach-dokumentov-ob-ukraine-smi--789629.html. [in Ukrainian]
Yakovlev, N. (1980). TsRU protiv SSSR [CIA vs USSR]. Moskva: Molodaya gvardiya. [in Russian]
Yarova, M. (2017). TsRU rassekretilo boleye 12 mln stranits arkhivnykh dokumentov: i tam yest’ Ukraina [The CIA has declassified more than 12 million pages of archival documents: and there is Ukraine]. URL: https://ain.ua/ru/2017/01/18/cru-okazalo-12-mln-arxivnyx-dokumentov-est-ukraina/. [in Russian]
millionov. (2017). 12 millionov stranits: TsRU rassekretilo dokumenty za 50 let deyatel'nosti [12 million pages: CIA declassified documents for 50 years of activity]. URL: https://bykvu.com/ua/bukvy/55308-12-millionov-stranits-tsru-rassekretilo-dokumenty-za-50-let-deyatelnosti/. [in Russian]
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
