POLISH AND UKRAINIAN LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT REFORMS (1998 – 2020): HISTORICAL AND COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

Authors

  • Tamara SHARAVARA PhD hab. (History), Full Professor, Professor of the Department of Humanities and Social Studies, Vice-rector of Scientific and Pedagogical Work and Prospective Development at Poltava State Agrarian University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6370-6663
  • Anastasiia NEKRIACH PhD hab. (Political Sciences), Full Professor, Professor of the Department of Humanities and Social Studies at Poltava State Agrarian University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5058-4145

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.28.287562

Abstract

The purpose of the article is a comparative analysis of the Polish and Ukrainian reforms of local self-government and sinlingling out the most significant European practices useful for Ukraine. The research methodology is based on the principles of systematicity, dialectics, reliability, a concrete and historical approach, logic. General scientific methods of analysis and synthesis, comparative, structural and functional, generalization, special methods of interview and content analysis have been used. The scientific novelty consists in the analysis of development peculiarities of local self-government bodies of the Republic of Poland in comparison with the Ukrainian realities, and the most relevant European practices for modern Ukraine have been suggested, which must be taken into account when establishing self-governing institutions under the conditions of power decentralization. The Conclusion. The structure and conceptual approaches in the organization of local self-government of the Republic of Poland have been studied, and information on self-government various branches operating in this country has been collected by means of interview and observation methods; it has been clarified how self-government branches became the most important provider of public services for their citizens, an important partner of international investments. It has been confirmed that the Polish commune truly became a school of democratic governance and contributed to development of civil society structures. The foundations of a close cooperation between the sołtys administration of Grobniki village, Głubszyce gmina and Nekhvoroshchanska community of Poltava region of Ukraine have been laid.

The achievements and problems accompanying the reboot of local government in Ukraine during decentralization have been outlined. Chief focus is on the possibility of introducing certain elements of the Polish experience into a domestic practice of self-governing institutions in order to increase efficiency of their functioning. In particular, it is about ensuring a full autonomous control by self-governing bodies over the sources of their own revenues and having the right to make decisions regarding their distribution, application of equalization principle of local budgets, creation of joint firms, associations with entities that carry out their activities within the framework of self-governing territories, involvement of population in local affairs management, election of officials at all levels of local self-government and, first of all, in the Ukrainian starosty districts, that are part of territorial communities, establishment of mutually beneficial partnership cooperation with international and domestic investors.

The European choice of Ukraine, which has gone through certain historical stages of democratization and formation of a civil society, contributes to realization of such tasks. It is the European choice that provides various opportunities for improving activities of local self-government bodies, their interaction with power structures at all levels of management and population, establishing constructive cooperation and dialogue with all interested institutions. That is why, the Polish model of a local government organization, which is built on the principles of subsidiarity, deconcentration, consensus, combining efforts of the state and self-governing units, effective legislative and legal regulation, deserves analysis and study. After all, a positive balance of transformations and changes that took place in this country really deserves not only a chief focus, but also implementation expediency in the Ukrainian practice, which gives reason to look at a further development and improvement of national self-government with optimism.

Key words: Ukraine, the Republic of Poland, sołtys administration, gmina, county, voivodship,
decentralization, local self-government, subsidiarity, the Polish model, European integration.

References

Averianova, N. & Voropaieva, T. (2020). Transformation of the Collective Identity of Ukrainian Citizens After the Revolution of Dignity (2014 – 2019). Kyiv-Mohyla Humanities Journal, 7, 45–71. [in English]

Doskich, L. S. (2022). Elektronni petytsii na rivni mistsevoho samovriaduvannia v Ukraini ta Polshchi [Electronic Petitions at the Level of Local Self-Government in Ukraine and Poland]. Derzhava i pravo: Zbirnyk naukovykh prats. Yurydychni i politychni nauky – State and law: Collection of scientific papers. Legal and political sciences, 92, 170–182. [in Ukrainian]

Dovhopolova, O. (2022). Mozhlyvi tendentsii perezavantazhennia lokalnykh identychnostei v Ukraini v sytuatsii viiny (pryklad Odesy) [Possible Trends of Rebooting Local Identities in Ukraine in a War Situation (the example of Odesa)]. Ideolohiia ta polityka – The Ideology and Politics Journal, 2 (21), 19–33. [in Ukrainian]

Fedorchenko-Kutuyev, P., Pyholenko, I. & Khomiak, A. (2023). Ukrainska derzhava mizh imperatyvamy demokratii ta povoiennoi modernizatsii [The Ukrainian state between the imperatives of democracy and post-war modernization]. Ideolohiia ta polityka – The Ideology and Politics Journal, 1 (23), 148–171. [in Ukrainian]

Havrylyshyn, B. (2009). Do efektyvnykh suspilstv: Dorohovkazy v maibutnie: dop. Rymskomu klubovi [Towards Effective Societies: Roadmaps to the Future: Supplement Club of Rome]. Uporiad. V. Rubtsov. Vyd. 3-tie, dopov. Kyiv: Univ. vyd-vo PULSARY. [in Ukrainian]

Holm-Hansen, Y., Kropp, S. (2022). Rehionalne riznomanittia Ukrainy: chy mozhlyva federalizatsiia? [Regional diversity of Ukraine: is federalization possible?]. Ideolohiia ta polityka – The Ideology and Politics Journal, 3 (22), 23–47. [in Ukrainian]

Hontsiazh, Ya. (Ed.). (2001). Samovriaduvannia ta terytorialna orhanizatsiia vlady v Polshchi [Self-Government and Territorial Organization of Power in Poland.]. Kyiv: Milenium; Vyd-vo UADU. [in Ukrainian]

Horbatenko, V. (2012). Rymskyi klub i orhanizatsiia transdystsyplinarnykh proektiv z dovhostrokovoho prohnozuvannia hlobalnykh problem [The Club of Rome and Organization of Transdisciplinary Projects on Long-term Forecasting of Global Problems]. Politychnyi menedzhment – Political management, 3, 52–64. [in Ukrainian].

Koliarska-Bobynska L. (Ed.) (2000). Chetyre reformy. Ot kontseptsyy do realyzatsyy [Four Reforms. From Concept to Implementation]. Varshava. URL: cyberleninka.ru/article/n/chetyre-reformy-ot-kontseptsii-do-realizatsii-referativnyy-obzor/viewer. [in Russian]

Kropp, S. & Osland, O. (2022). Politychni reformy v Ukraini ta yikh vplyv na sotsialnu zghurtovanist: sproba sotsiolohichnoi kontseptualizatsii [Political reforms in Ukraine and their impact on social cohesion: an attempt at sociological conceptualization]. Ideolohiia ta polityka – The Ideology and Politics Journal, 3 (22), 3–22. [in Ukrainian]

Lopushynskyi, I. P. (2019). Upravlinnia mistsevymy biudzhetamy v umovakh detsentralizatsii. [Management of local budgets under conditions of decentralization]. Hromadivska model samovriaduvannia v Ukraini: kolektyvna monohrafiia, (pp. 222–259). Kherson: Knyzhkove vydavnytstvo FOP Vyshemyrskyi V. S. [in Ukrainian]

Malynovskyi, V. Ya. (2016). Svitovyi dosvid orhanizatsii mistsevoho samovriaduvannia [World Experience of Organizing Local self-Government]. Mistseve samovriaduvannia v Ukraini: yevrointehratsiinyi shliakh: kolektyvna monohrafia, (pp. 53–106). Kyiv: RIDNA MOVA. [in Ukrainian]

Matviyenko, A. S. (2015). Polityko-pravovi zasady terytorialnoi orhanizatsii derzhavy: svitovyi dosvid i Ukraina [Political and Legal Foundations of Territorial Organization of the State: World Experience and Ukraine]. Kyiv: In-t derzhavy i prava im. V. M. Koretskoho NAN Ukrainy. [in Ukrainian]

Monolatiy, I. S. & Derevianko, S. M. (2022). Model mistsevoho samovriaduvannia Respubliky Polshcha: dosvid dlia Ukrainy [Model of Local Self-Government of the Republic of Poland: Experience for Ukraine]. Derzhava i pravo: Zbirnyk naukovykh prats. Yurydychni i politychni nauky. – State and Law: Collection of scientific papers. Legal and political sciences, 92, 194–214. [in Ukrainian]

Nekhvoroshchanska terytorialna hromada. (2023). Nekhvoroshchanska terytorialna hromada – Prodovzhuiemo vyvchaty osoblyvosti diialnosti orhaniv mistsevoho samovriaduvannia u Polshchi [Nekhvoroshcha Territorial Community – We continue to study the peculiarities of the activities of local self-government bodies in Poland]. URL: https://nchvorosha-gromada.gov.ua/news/1680931161/ [in Ukrainian]

Olenkovska, L. P. (2016). Detsentralizatsiini protsesy yak osnova mistsevoho samovriaduvannia [Decentralization Processes as the Basis of Local Self-Government]. Mistseve samovriaduvannia v umovakh detsentralizatsii vlady v Ukraini: Kolektyvna monohrafiia, (pp. 241–297). Kyiv: RIDNA MOVA. [in Ukrainian]

Orhanizatsiia mistsevoho samovriaduvannia respubliky Polshcha [Organization of Local Self-Government of the Republic of Poland]. URL: https://uplan.org.ua/analytics/orhanizatsiia-mistsevoho-samovriaduvannia-respubliky-polshcha/ [in Ukrainian]

Seinenskyi povit (Pidliasne voievodstvo, Respublika Polshcha) [Seinen County (Podlas Voivodeship, Republic of Poland)]. URL: uk.db-city.com/Polshcha-Pidliaske-voievodstvo-Seinenskyi povit [in Ukrainian]

Shapoval, V. M. (Ed.). (2018). Konstytutsiia Polskoi Respubliky [Constitution of the Republic of Poland]. Kyiv: Moskalenko O. M. [in Ukrainian]

Statystychnyi dovidnyk. (2001). Statystychnyi dovidnyk Polshchi 2000 [Statistical Handbook of Poland 2000]. Varshava: GUS. [in Ukrainian]

Varshavskyi povit (Mazovetske voievodstvo, Respublika Polshcha) [Warsaw County (Mazowiec Voivodeship, Republic of Poland)]. URL: uk.db-city.com/Polshcha-Mazovetske-voievodstvo-Varshava. [in Ukrainian]

Vuichik, M. & Hrabets, M. (2000). Orhanizatsiia ta pryntsypy funktsionuvannia orhaniv samovriaduvannia v Polshchi [Organization and principles of functioning of self-government bodies in Poland]. Varshava. [in Ukrainian].

Yevropeiska khartiia mistsevoho samovriaduvannia [European Charter of Local Self-Government]. Strasburh, 15 zhovtnia 1985 roku. URL: zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/994_036#Text. [in Ukrainian]

Zakon “Pro dostup do publichnoi informatsii”. (2021). Zakon “Pro dostup do publichnoi informatsii” [Law “On Access to Public Information”]. Visnyk zakoniv, 12, 1198. [in Ukrainian]

Zakon “Pro mistsevi referendumy”. (2000). Zakon “Pro mistsevi referendumy”. [Law “On Local Referendums”]. Visnyk zakoniv, 88, 985. [in Ukrainian]

Zakon Polshchi “Pro hminne samovriaduvannia” [Law of Poland “On Commune Self-Government”]. URL: https://www.csi.org.ua/publications/zakon-pro-gminne-samovryaduvannya-vid-8-b/. [in Ukrainian]

Zakon Polshchi “Pro povitove samovriaduvannia” vid 5 chervnia 1998 roku. [Law of Poland “On County Self-Government”]. URL: https://www.csi.org.ua/publications/zakon-pro-povitove-samovryaduvannya-v [in Ukrainian]

Zakon Polshchi “Pro samovriaduvannia voievodstv” vid 5 chervnia 1998 roku. [Law of Poland “On Self-Government of Voivodeships”]. URL: https://www.csi.org.ua/publications/zakon-pro-samovryaduvannya-voyevodstva-v/ [in Ukrainian]

Downloads

Published

2023-09-23

How to Cite

SHARAVARA, T. ., & NEKRIACH, A. (2023). POLISH AND UKRAINIAN LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT REFORMS (1998 – 2020): HISTORICAL AND COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS. EAST EUROPEAN HISTORICAL BULLETIN, (28), 223–238. https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.28.287562

Issue

Section

Articles