PATRIOTS & CRITICS: THE STORY OF HOW PUBLIC RECEPTIONS OF WORLD WAR I IN THE RUSSIAN EMPIRE CHANGED

Authors

  • Ruslan KUTSYK PhD (History), Assistant Professor at the Chair of Ukrainian History, Faculty of History and Philosophy, Borys Grinchenko Kyiv University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5631-9385

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.22.253732

Abstract

The purpose of the research is to outline the main features of society’s reaction to the outbreak of World War I and the subsequent transformational changes in the mood of different population groups in the course of the war events. The methodology of the research is based on the principles of historicism, the effectiveness of systematic and scientific using national (analysis, synthesis, scientific abstraction) and special and historical (historical and comparative, retrospective and problematic) methods. The Scientific Novelty. For the first time the peculiarities of the moods of different population groups of the Ukrainian lands of the Russian Empire in 1914 – 1917 were comprehensively presented, taking into account not only the social status of the person, but also the age peculiarities and personal motives; clearly outlines the major stages of changing society’s reception and understanding of World War I events. The Conclusions. Therefore, the initial stage of the war was marked by widespread patriotism, which, despite of its “mass” nature, had a differentiated, ambivalent and permanent character during the years of 1914 – 1917. The majority of “ardent” patriots were wealthy people who, owing to their privileged and financial position avoided military service and practically didn’t participate in the hostilities, or representatives of ultra-monarchical circles. For some people the war was a way of showing their loyalty to the government, but for the others it was an opportunity to make money and enrich themselves. Other groups of the population were overwhelmed by a sense of patriotism and liberation struggle, though the main reason for this was not the love for the “great tsarist Motherland”, but understanding of the need to protect their “small homeland”. A similar vision and reception of the war was typical of the soldiers’ environment, as it was based on village natives. In the early years of the war, the behavior of soldiers was determined by the humble, patient, and self-righteous fulfillment of their military duty. Delaying the timing of the war, defeats at the front, increasing of the number of victims, growing economic crisis triggered a process of destabilization inside the country. Distrust and dissatisfaction were spreading in the society. Negative trends began to show up in the army, in particular, a decline of patriotism, morale and religiosity. As a result, in 1916 – 1917, measures, adopted by the Russian imperial government in order to control the socio-political situation, could no longer hide the true situation and restrain the serious transformations in the mass public consciousness. The increase of political activity in the national consciousness of the Ukrainians was a notable phenomenon. It also was one of the important preconditions for the revolutionary events and the development of the Ukrainian statehood in the 1917s – 1920s.

Key words: World War I, Russian Empire, Ukrainian people, public consciousness, public mood, patriotism, criticism.

References

Astashov, A. (2014). Russkiy front v 1914 – nachale 1917 goda: voennyiy opyit i sovremennost [Russian Front in 1914 – the beginning of 1917: military experience and modernity]. Moscow: Novyy khronograf, 740 p. [in Russian]

Astashov, A. (2016). Moralnyy dukh i nastroeniya russkoy armii v Pervoy mirovoy voyne [Morale and Mood of the Russian Army in World War I]. In M. Yu. Myagkova, K. A. Pakhaliuk (Ed.), Ot protivostoyaniya ideologiy k sluzheniyu idealam: rossiyskoe obshchestvo v 1914–1945 gg.: sb. st. (pp. 33–46). Moscow: The Novyy khronograf. [in Russian]

Bonnerjee, S. (2019) “The lure of war”: reconsidering the motivations of nurses to volunteer in World War I. Women’s History Review, 28 (7), 1096–1114. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/09612025.2019.1608683 [in English]

Brusilov, A. (2013). Moi vospominaniya [My memories]. Moscow: Veche, 288 p. [in Russian]

Daly, J. (2001). Pressa i gosudarstvo v Rossii (1906–1917 gg.) [Repression and Freedom of the Press in Late Imperial Russia]. Voprosyi istorii, 10, 25–45. [in Russian]

Derzhavnyi arkhiv Khmelnytskoi oblasti [SAKhO – State Archives of the Khmelnytskyi Oblast]

Derzhavnyi arkhiv Kyivskoi oblasti [SAKO – State Archives of Kyiv Oblast]

Dornik, W., Kasianov, G., Leidinger, H., Lieb, P., Miller, A., Musial, B. & Rasevych, V. (2015). Ukraina mizh samovyznachenniam ta okupatsiieiu: 1917 – 1922 roky [Ukraine between Self-determination and Occupation: 1917 – 1922]. Kyiv: Nika-Center, 512 p. [in Ukrainian]

Doroshenko, D. (1969). Moi spomyny pro nedavnie-mynule (1914 – 1920). V chotyrokh chastynakh: Halytska Ruina – Doba Tsentralnoi Rady – Doba Hetmanshchyny – Doba Dyrektorii [My memories of the recent past (1914 – 1920). In four parts: Galicia Ruin – Age of the Central Council – Age of the Hetmanate – Age of the Directory]. Munich: Ukrainske vydavnytstvo, 543 p. [in Ukrainian]

Guenther, K. (2017). A Question of Loyalty: German Churches in Reading During the First World War. Pennsylvania History, 84 (3), 325–353 [in English]

Halagan, M. (2005). Z moikh spomyniv (1880-ti – 1920 r.): Dokumentalno-khudozhnie vydannia [From my Memoirs (the 1880s – 1920s): Documentary and artistic pub]. Kyiv: Tempora. 656 p. [in Ukrainian]

Hordienko, H. (1976). Pid shchytom Marsa: Spohady [Under the Shield of Mars: Memoris]. (Vol. I). Philadelphia, 256 p. [in Ukrainian]

Hubertus, F. (1995). Patriotic Culture in Russia during World War I. Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press, 229 p. [in English]

Kolyada, I. (2018). Reaktsiia miskoho naselennia Pravoberezhnoi Ukrainy na pochatok Pershoi svitovoi viiny: sproba retrospektyvy [Reaction of the Urban Population of the Ukraine at the Beginning of the First World War: an Attempt of Retrospective]. Hileya: naukovyy visnyk. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats’, 132, 27–30. [in Ukrainian]

Koshyts, O. (1948). Spohady. Chastyna II. [Memories. Part II]. Winnipeg: Kultura i osvita, 272 p. [in Ukrainian]

Kovalevskyi, M. (1960). Pry dzherelakh borotby. Spomyny, vrazhennia, refleksii [At sources of struggle. Memories, impressions, reflections]. Innsbruck, 719 p. [in Ukrainian]

Lohr, E. (2004) The Russian Press and the “Internal Peace” at the Beginning of World War I. In Troy R.E. Paddock (Ed). A call to arms: propaganda, public opinion, and newspapers in the Great War (pp. 91–113). Westport, Conn.: Praeger Publishers. [in English]

Machen, E. (2013) Soldiers of Faith behind the Lines: religious women and community patriotism during World War I in France. Women’s History Review, 22 (1), 31–50. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/09612025.2012.724919 [in English]

Monger, D. (2018). Tangible Patriotism during the First World War: Individuals and the Nation in British Propaganda, War & Society, 37 (4), 244–261. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/07292473.2018.1496786 [in English]

Novitskiy. (1916, February 9). Sila dukha [Strength of Mind]. Armeyskiy Vestnik, 231, 4. [in Russian]

Oldenburg, S. (1949). Tsarstvovanie imperatora Nikolaya II. Tom 2 [Reign of Emperor Nicholas II. Volume 2]. Myunkhen: Izdanie Obshchestva rasprostraneniya russkoy natsionalnoy i patrioticheskoy literatury, 260 p. [in Russian]

Petrov, Yu. (Ed.). (2014). Rossiya v gody Pervoy mirovoy voyny: ekonomicheskoe polozhenie, sotsialnye protsessy, politicheskiy krizis [Russia during World War I: economic situation, social processes, political crisis]. Moscow: Politicheskaya ehnciklopediya, 982 p. [in Russian]

Porshneva, O. (2004). Krestyane, rabochie i soldaty Rossii nakanune i v gody Pervoy mirovoy voyny [Peasants, Workers and Soldiers of Russia before and during World War I]. Moscow: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya, 368 p. [in Russian]

Reient, O. & Serdiuk, O. (2004). Zahostrennia superechnostei v imperskomu suspilstvi u roky Pershoi svitovoi viiny (lypen 1914 – liutyi 1917 rr.) [Aggravation of contradictions in imperial society during World War I (July 1914 – February 1917)]. Problemy istorii Ukrainy XIX – pochatku XX st., 7, 5–47. [in Ukrainian]

Schneider, G. (1999). Zur Mobilisierung der Heimatfront. Das Nageln sogenannter Kriegswahrzeichen im Ersten Weltkrieg [The mobilisation of the home front: The nailing of the so-called war landmarks in World War I]. Zeitschrift fur Volkskunde, 95 (1), 32–62 [in German]

Senyavskaya, E. (1997). Obraz vraga v soznanii uchastnikov Pervoy mirovoy voyny [The image of the enemy in the minds of the participants of World War I]. Voprosy istorii, 3, 140–156. [in Russian]

Shavelskyi, G. (1954). Vospominaniya poslednego protopresvitera Russkoy armii i flota [Memoirs of the Last Protopresbyter of the Russian Army and Navy]. New York: izdanie imeni Chekhova. URL: http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/shavelsky_gi/index.html [in Russian]

Starovoitenko, I. (Ed.). (2005). Lysty Leonida Zhebunova do Yevhena Chykalenka. 1907 – 1919 roky [Letters from Leonid Zhebunyov to Yevgeny Chykalenko. 1907 – 1919]. Kyiv, 251 p. [in Ukrainian]

Sukhova, O. (2014). Pervaya mirovaya voyna kak vyzov russkoy mentalnosti: massovye nastroeniya v provintsii v 1914 – 1917 gg. [World War I as a challenge to the Russian mentality: mass sentiments in the province in 1914 – 1917]. In S. M. Iskhakov, Yu. A. Petrov (Ed.), Rossiya i Pervaya mirovaya voyna: ekonomicheskie problemyi, obschestvennyie nastroeniya, mezhdunarodnyie otnosheniya: sb. st. (pp. 121–140). Moscow. [in Russian]

Tison, G. (2015). French pupils between the two wars of 1870 – 1871 and 1914 – 1918 Reading books and their patriotic consciousness. History of Education & Childrens Literature, 10 (1), 393–409. [in English]

Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi istorychnyi arkhiv Ukrainy v m. Kyievi [CSHAUK –Central State Historical Archives of Ukraine in Kyiv]

Vilshanska, O. (2014a). Povsiakdenne zhyttia i suspilni nastroi naselennia [Everyday Life and Public Mood of the Population]. In O.P. Reient (Ed). Velyka viina 1914 – 1918 rr. i Ukraina. U dvokh knyhakh. Knyha 1. Istorychni narysy (pp. 440–467). Kyiv: TOV “Vydavnytstvo “KLIO”. [in Ukrainian]

Vilshanska, O. (2014b). Suspilni nastroi v Ukraini pid chas Pershoi svitovoi viiny [Public Mood in Ukraine during World War I]. In V. A. Smolii (Ed.), Persha svitova viina y Ukraini (do 100-richchia pochatku Velykoi viiny): tezy dopovidei Vseukrainskoi naukovoi konferentsii z mizhnarodnoiu uchastiu (Kyiv–Cherkasy, 25–26 veresnia 2014 r.). (pp. 63–66). Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy. [in Ukrainian]

Voyna i derevnya (s. Krivoe, Skvirskogo uezda) [War and Village (the village of Krivoe, Skvirsky district)]. (1914, August 29). Kievskaya zemskaya gazeta, 33, 15. [in Russian]

Zolotarev, V. (Ed.) (2014). Yevropa i Rossiya v ogne Pervoy mirovoy voyny. K 100-letiyu nachala voyny [Europe and Russia in the fire of World War I. To the 100th anniversary of the start of the war]. Moscow: INEHS, RUBIN, 2014, 880 p. [in Russian]

Downloads

Published

2022-03-27

Issue

Section

Articles