WHO ARE THE ANCIENT BULGARIANS – ETHNOS OR MILITARY COMMUNITY?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.21.246898Abstract
The “Proto-Bulgarian problem” is a traditional topic in Bulgarian medieval studies, as well as the questions related to the Bulgarians' ethnic origin, the location of their ancestral homeland, their early history and their role in the formation of Bulgarian statehood. These topics were and remain the most important ones in the development of the historical consciousness of the Bulgarian people, and at the same time leave many unresolved issues. The purpose of the research is to outline the problematic points which exist in the literature relatively to the origin of the Bulgarians, and to give arguments for our point of view, who the ancient Bulgarians could really be. Research methodology. We used both general scientific methods (analytical, logical), historical (chronological, historical and comparative), and source studies – heuristic, critical. The scientific novelty is determined by the fact that the article substantiates the point of view that the term “Bulgar” was not an ethnos term at the time of the presence of the ancient Bulgars in the Eastern European steppes, but it meant belonging to a certain social status, namely – the military elite. Its maturation into an ethnos term took place later – when the Bulgarians moved to the Balkans and began the process of their own state formation. Formations similar to the medieval Bulgarian military class existed in other nations until the Middle Ages and later. The Conclusion. The results of our study gave grounds for the following conclusions. The ancient Bulgarians were not an ethnic but social-class union, a military community; the term “military order” could be used. The tradition to create such military orders resided in the Indo-Aryan tribes and their ancestors from ancient times and can be traced back to the end of the Middle Ages in the community of the Ukrainian Cossacks. Destruction of the Zaporozhian Sich by the Russian authorities in the ХVІІІth century interrupted this ancient tradition forever
Key words: Bulgarians, Military order, ethnos term (ethnonym), “proto-Bulgarian issue”, class and social association.
References
Ageeva, V. V. (2014). Istoriografiya “prabolgarskoi problemy” i “varyazhskogo voprosa” kak relevantnyi material dlya sravnitel'no-istoricheskogo issledovaniya [Historiography of the “pro-Bulgarian problem” and “Varangian question” as relevant material for comparative historical research]. Siberian Journal of Life Sciences and Agriculture, 5.1, 230–239. doi: https://doi.org/10.12731/wsd-2014-5.1-230-239 [in Russian]
Ageeva, V. V. (2012). Osobennosti formirovaniya i razvitiya rannei bolgarskoi gosudarstvennosti (konets VІІ – pervaya polovina ІX vv) [Features of the formation and development of early Bulgarian statehood (the end of the 7th – the first half of the 9th centuries)]. Aktualnyye problem gumanitarnykh nauk: sbornik nauchnykh trudov studentov, aspirantov i molodykh uchenykh 5–6 aprelya – Actual problems of the humanities: collection of scientific works of students, graduate students and young scientists April 5–6, (pp. 322–324). Tomsk. [in Russian]
Artamonov, M. I. (1962). Istoriya khazar [History of Khazars]. Leningrad: Yzdatelstvo Hosudarstvennoho Еrmytazha, 523 p. [in Russian]
Bakirov, M. (2005). Prototyurki: iznachal'naya prarodina, rannie plemena i yazyk, istoriya i etnokul'tura [Pro-Turkic: Primordial Homeland, Early Tribes and Language, History and Ethnoculture]. Kazan': Tatarskoe knyzhnoe yzdatelstvo, 463 p. [in Russian]
Bariev, R. K. (2005). Volzhskie bulgary: istoriya i kul'tura [The Volga Bulgars: history and culture]. Sankt-Peterburg: Agat, 304 p. [in Russian]
Bezverkha, V. (2015). Kontseptsіya poyavi Bolgars'koї derzhavi u tvorchii spadshchinі V. Zlatars'kogo [The Concept of the Bulgarian state emerged in the works V. Zlatarsky]. Naukovі zapiski Kіrovograds'kogo derzhavnogo pedagogіchnogo unіversitetu іm. V. Vinnichenka. Serіya “Іstorichnі nauki” – Scientific Notes of the Kirovohrad V. Vynnychenko State Pedagogical University. Series “Historical Sciences”, (19), 202–206. [in Ukrainian]
Borysova, O. V. (2005). Geneza naukovoї paradigmi іstorichnogo protsesu v serednі vіki (V–XV st.) [Genesis of the scientific paradigm of the historical process in the Middle Ages (the Vth – the XVth centuries)]. Lugans'k: Al'ma mater, 456 р. [in Ukrainian]
Borysova, O. V. (2021). Zasnovnyk Dunaiskoi Bolharii khan Asparukh i Ukraina. [The founder of the Danube Bulgaria was Khan Asparuh and Ukraine]. Osvita i nauka u minlyvomu sviti: problemy ta perspektyvy rozvytku: мaterialy III Mizhnarodnoi naukovoi konferentsii, (II), (pp. 109–111). Dnipro. [in Ukrainian].
Borysova, O. V. (2008). Kіmmerіitsі u “Formatsії ukraїns'koї natsії” Vadima Shcherbakіvs'kogo [Kimmeriycy is in “Structure of Ukrainian nation” Vadima Scherbakivskogo]. Gіleya. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats. Іstorіya. Polіtologіya. Fіlosofіya. – Gileya. Collection of scientific works. History, Political Science, Philosophy, (17), 152–155. [in Ukrainian]
Borysova, O. V. (2018). Povіdomlennya ottsya Paisіya Khіlendars'kogo pro volz'ku prabat'kіvshchinu bolgar [The message of Father Paisii Hilendarski about the Volga Ancestral Homeland of the Bulgarians]. Zbirnyk materialiv naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii Lugans'kogo natsіonal'nogo agrarnogo unіversitetu – Proceedings of the scientific-practical conference of Luhansk National Agrarian University, (рр. 95–98). Kharkіv. [in Ukrainian].
Borysova, O. V. (2010). Relіgіinii chinnik u geopolіtichnikh ustremlіnnyakh elіt Ukraїni v dobu Seredn'ovіchchya [Religious factor in geopolitical appetences of the elites of Ukraine in the Middle Ages]. Lugans'k: DZ “Lugans'kii natsіonal'nii unіversitet іm. Tarasa Shevchenka”, 340 р. [in Ukrainian].
Borysova, O. & Karpitskyi, N. (2019). Father Paisii Hilendarski`s message about the Volga ancestral home of the Bulgarians as a source of formation of national historical consciousness. Journal of International Eastern European Studies / Uluslararası Doğu Avrupa Araştırmaları Dergisi, 1 (2), 247–260. [in English]
Braginskaya, N. V. (1990). Kto takie mirmidontsy? [Who are the Myrmidons?]. Balkanskie chteniya. 1: simpozium po strukture teksta: tezisy i materialy – Balkan Readings. 1: symposium on the structure of the text: abstracts and materials? (pp. 41–45). Moskva. [in Russian]
Burmov, A. (1936). B’lgarite v Priazovieto [The Bulgarians in the Azov Region]. Otets Paisii – Father Paisii, Sofiia, 3, 97–104. [in Bulgarian]
Butba, V. F. (2005). Trudy [Works]. Sukhum: Dom pechati. 216 р. [in Russian].
Chichurov, I. S. (1980). Vizantiiskie istoricheskie sochineniya: “Khronografiya” Feofana, “Breviarii” Nikifora: Teksty, perevod, kommentarii [Byzantine historical works: “Chronography” of Theophanes, “Breviary” of Nicephorus: Texts, Translation, Commentary]. Moskva: Nauka, 216 р. [in Russian]
Dobrev, I. (2005). Zlatnoto s"krovishche na b"lgarskite khanove ot Atila do Simeon [The Golden Treasure of the Bulgarian Khans from Attila to Simeon]. Sofia: Riva, 510 р. [in Bulgarian]
Dobrev, I. (2011). B"lgarite za ruskiya narod, d"rzhava i kultura [The Bulgarians for the Russian People, State and Culture]. Sofia: Blgarska multimedijna kompaniya, 982 р. [in Bulgarian]
Dobrev, P. (2005). Saga za drevnite b"lgari: Prarodina i stranstvaniya [The Saga of the Ancient Bulgarians: Ancestor and Wanderings]. Sofia: Kama, 126 р. [in Bulgarian]
Fіnnіk, S. V. (2014). Etnonіm narodu bulgar u zv’yazku z їkh etnіchnim pokhodzhennyam [The Bulgars Ethnonym Related to its Ethnic Origin]. Sums'kii іstoriko-arkhіvnii zhurnal – Sumy Historical and Archival Journal, 23, 90–100. [in Ukrainian]
Fіnnіk, S. V. (2018). Etnogenez bulgar і pereselennya kochovikh plemen u Skhіdnu Єvropu v V stolіttі n. e. [Ethnogenesis of the Bulgars and the Migration of Nomadic Tribes to Eastern Europe in the 5th century AD]. Іstorіya ta geografіya: Zbirnyk naukovykh prats – History and Geography: collection pf scientific works, Kharkіv, (54), 81–88. [in Ukrainian] doi: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1476243
Gadlo, A. V. (1968). O chernykh i vnutrennikh bolgarakh. Odna iz spornykh problem istoricheskoi etnografii yuzhnorusskikh stepei [About Black and Domestic Bulgarians. One of the Controversial Problems of the Historical Ethnography of the Southern Russian Steppes]. Geograficheskoe obshchestvo. Doklady po etnografii – Geographical Society. Ethnography reports, (6), 3–25. Leningrad. [in Russian]
Ganina, N. A. (2011). Krymsko-gotskii yazyk [The Crimean-Gothic Language]. Sankt-Peterburg: Aleteiya, 288 р. [in Russian]
Gening, V. F. & Khalikov, A. Kh. (1964). Rannie bolgary na Volge (Bol'she-Tarkhanskii mogil'nik) [Early Bulgarians on the Volga (Bolshe-Tarkhan burial ground)]. Moskva: Nauka, 200 р. [in Russian]
Gyndyn, L. A. (Comps.) (1994). Svod drevneishykh pysmennуkh yzvestyi o slavianakh [The Collection of the Oldest Written Sources about Slavs]. (Vol. 1: 1st– 6th centuries). Moskva: Nauka, Hlavnaia redaktsyia vostochnoi lyteratury, 470 p. [in Russian]
Gr"tski izvori za b"lgarskata istoriya. (1954). Gr"tski izvori za b"lgarskata istoriya [Greek Sources on Bulgarian History]. (Vol. 1). Sofiya: Blharskata Akademyia na Naukyte, 240 р. [in Bulgarian]
Kaloianov, V. (2019). Protobolhary v stepakh Pivdennoi Rosii ta Ukrainy. [Proto-Bulgarians in the steppes of Southern Russia and Ukraine]. Visnyk Natsionalnoho istoryko-arkheolohichnoho zapovidnyka “Kam’iana Mohyla”, 4, 104–114. Zaporizhzhia: Dyke Pole. [in Ukrainian]
Karasev, I. (2010). O proyavlenii svoistv Balkanskogo yazykovogo soyuza v adygeiskom yazyke [On the Manifestation of the Properties of the Balkan Language Union in the Adyghe Language.]. BVLGARI – BULGARIANS. URL: https://www.bulgari-istoria-2010.com/booksRu/I_Karasev_Balk_Ez_sojus.pdf [in Russian]
Lebedev, G. S. (2005). Epokha vikingov v Severnoi Evrope i na Rusi [The Era of the Vikings in Northern Europe and Rus]. Sankt-Peterburg: Evraziya, 640 р. [in Russian]
Merpert, N. Ya. (1957). K voprosu o drevneishikh bolgarskikh plemenakh [On the Question of the Oldest Bulgarian tribes]. Kazan': Gosudarstvenуi muzei TASS, 366 р. [in Russian]
Mіshko, S. (1981). Naris rann'oї іstorії Rusi-Ukrainy [Essay on the Early History of Rus-Ukraine]. New-York-Toronto-Munchen: Ukrainske istorychne tovarystvo, 228 р. [in Ukrainian]
Napol'skikh, V. V. (2006). Balto-slavyanskii yazykovoi komponent v Nizhnem Prikam'e v ser. I tys. n.e. [Balto-Slavic Language Component in the Lower Kama Region in the Middle of 1-st Millennium AD]. Slavyanovedenie – Slavic Studies, 2, 3–19. [in Russian]
Novosel'tsev, A. P. (1990). Khazarskoe gosudarstvo i ego rol' v istorii Vostochnoi Evropy i Kavkaza [Khazarian State and its Role in the History of Eastern Europe and the Caucasus]. Moskva: Nauka, 266 р. [in Russian]
Polyvannyi, D. I. (2000). Kul'turnoe svoeobrazie srednevekovoi Bolgarii v kontekste vizantiisko-slavyanskoi obshchnosti [The Cultural Identity of Medieval Bulgaria in the Context of the Byzantine-Slavic Community]. Ivanovo: Ivanovskii gosudarstvennyi unyversytet, 290 р. [in Russian]
Sedov, V. V. (1995). Slavyane v rannem srednevekov'e [Slavs in the Early Middle Ages]. Moskva: Fond arkheologii, 416 р. [in Russian]
Sedov, V. V. (2002). Slavyane: Istoriko-arkheologicheskoe issledovanie [The Slavs: Historical and Archaeological Research]. Moskva: Yazyki slavyanskoi kul'tury, 618 р. [in Russian]
Shcherbakіvs'kii, V. (1967). Formatsіya ukraїns'koї natsії [Formation of Ukrainian Nation]. Vizvol'nii shlyakh – The Way of Liberation, 5 (230), 559–571. [in Ukrainian]
Smirnov, A. P. (1951). Volzhskie bulgary [Volga Bulgarians]. Moskva: Gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij muzej, 276 р. [in Russian]
Stefanov, Yu. A. (2013). O bolgarakh i etnicheskikh protsessakh v Priazov'e v pervom tysyacheletii nashei ery [About Bulgarians and Ethnic Processes in the Azov Region in the 1-st Millennium AD]. Aktual'nye voprosy obshchestvennykh nauk: sotsiologiya, politologiya, filosofiya, istoriya: sbornyk statei po materyalam ХХ mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-praktycheskoi konferentsyy – Actual Questions of Social Sciences: Sociology, political Science, Philosophy, History: Proceeding of 20-th International Scientific and Practical Conference (pp. 141–148). Novosibirsk. [in Russian]
Tafaev, G. I. (2010). Bolgarskaya tsivilizatsiya v issledovaniyakh uchenykh Srednego Povolzh'ya [Bulgarian Civilization in the Researches of Scientists of the Middle Volga Region]. Cheboksary: Izdatelstvo GUP IPK “Chuvashiya”, 163 р. [in Russian].
The Chronicle of John Malalas (1986). Translation by E. Jenkis ets. Melbourne, 413 р.
Tolochko, P. P. (Ed.). (1994). Davnia istoriia Ukrainy [Ancient history of Ukraine]. (Vol. 1). Kyiv: Lybid, 235 р. [in Ukrainian]
Tortika, A. A. (2006). Severo-Zapadnaya Khazariya v kontekste istorii Vostochnoy Yevropy (vtoraya polovina VII – tretya chetvert Х v.) [Northwestern Khazaria in the context of the history of Eastern Europe (second half of the 7th – third quarter of the 10th century)]. Kharkiv: Kharkovskaya gosudarstvennaya akademiya kultury, 553 р. [in Russian]
Trubachev, O. N. (1999). Indoarica v Severnom Prichernomor'e [Indoarica in the Northern Black Sea Region]. Moskva: Nauka, 320 р. [in Russian]
Tuallagov, A. A. (1997). K voprosu o proiskhozhdenii rannikh alan [On the question of the Origin of the Early Alans]. Stratum+. Sbornik: Peterburgskii arkheologicheskii vestnik – Stratum+. Collection. Petersburg Archaeological Bulletin. URL: http://stratum.ant.md/. [in Russian]
Vasil'eva, N. I. (2009). Velikaya Skifiya [The Great Scythia]. Akademiya Trinitarizma – Academy of Trinities, 15. 03. URL: http://www.trinitas.ru/rus/000/z0000001-120.htm [in Russian]
Voinikov, Zh. (2016). Drevnie bolgary – kto oni? Novyi vzglyad na staryi vopros [Ancient Bulgarians – Who are they? A New Look at an Old Question.]. Drinovs'kii zbіrnik. Sofіya-Kharkіv. (19), 5–19. doi: https://doi.org/10.26565/DS.2016.09. [in Russian]
Yukhas, P. (1985). Tyurko-b"lgari i madzhari: Vliyanie na Tyurksko-b"lgarskata kultura v"rkhu madzharite [The Turkic-Bulgarians and Magyars: Influence of the Turkic-Bulgarian Culture on the Magyars]. Sofia: Izdatelstvo na Blgarskata akademiya na naukite, 455 р. [in Bulgarian]
Zhikh, M. I. (2011). K probleme rekonstruktsii samonazvaniya nositelei imen'kovskoi kul'tury [On the Problem of Reconstruction of the Self-Designation of the Bearers of the Imenkovsk Culture]. Sborniki konferentsii NITs Sotsiosfera – Collection of Conferences of SRC Sociosphere, (42), 15–37. [in Russian]
Zlatarski, Vasil N. (1972). Istoriya na b"lgarskata d"rzhava prez srednite vekove [History of the Bulgarian State in the Middle Ages]. (Vol. І., Part 1). Sofiya: Nauka i izkustvo, 485 p. [in Bulgarian]
Zolin, P. (2009). Eruly sloven-rusy budiny boloto. Proza. ru. URL: http//www.proza.ru/2009/08/26/913. [in Russian]
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
