POLAND’S FOREIGN POLICY CONCEPTS TRADITIONS AND INNOVATIONS REGARDING UKRAINE (the XXth – theBEGINNING OF the XXIst CENTURY)

Authors

  • Lyudmyla STRILCHUK PhD hab. (History), Professor of World History Department, Lesia Ukrainka East European National University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0700-6080
  • Oleksandr DOBRZHANSKYI PhD hab. (History), Professor, Dean of Political Science History and International Relations Faculty, Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3817-188X

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.18.226553

Abstract

In the modern world, the state’s foreign policy is one of the supporting foundations of statehood, and therefore the study of the foreign policy concepts formation and implementation experience is relevant and necessary for the development of the modern interstate and good neighborly relations between Ukraine and Poland. The Polish political elite, in different historical periods, distinguished visions about Ukraine clearly, its role and significance for Rzeczpospolita (Commonwealth), and these visions remained constant, actualized over time, or, conversely, acquired new shapes and coloring. The Piast and the Jagiellonian concepts have been the main Poland’s foreign policy concepts since the beginning of the XXth century, and continue to be of utmost importance and that new or existing foreign policy doctrines have been created or developed based on them. The article depicts Poland’s foreign policy concepts evolution regarding Ukraine, in particular, and the eastern vector of Polish politics in general. The purpose of the research is to analyze and compare Poland’s foreign policy concepts evolution towards Ukraine and to study the factors that influenced the transformation of these concepts. The methodology of the research is based on the principles of historicism in the unity of all its components, systematization and scientificity. The interdisciplinary research is focused on the involvement of historical comparative and historical systemic methods, methods of microhistorical analysis. The scientific novelty is that there is the continuation of studies, which were initiated by domestic, Polish and other foreign researchers, in particular on Poland’s foreign policy concepts formation and implementation in the eastern direction and on Ukraine in particular. The Conclusions. The historical traditions of Poland’s eastern foreign policy vector are obvious, and although the Polish eastern policy forms may have changed, its content has balanced between two established concepts: the Jagiellonian and the Piast. The Republic of Poland having used the positive experience of the past and striving to have a reliable ally on its eastern border, builds a modern eastern policy vector in which Ukraine is given one of the leading roles in the best traditions of the Jagiellonian foreign policy doctrine.

Key words: Poland, Ukraine, foreign policy, Jagiellonian concept, Piast concept, Prometheanism, incorporation, eastern policy.

References

Dodonov, R. (Ed.). (2019). Skladni pytannya istorychnoyi pamʺyati u paradyhmi dialohichnosti kulʹtur: Kolektyvna monohrafiya [Complex issues of historical memory in the paradigm of dialogic cultures: A collective monograph]. Bilostok: BV, 292 p.

Fedorowicz, K. (2004). Ukraina w polskiej polityce wschodniej w latach 1989 – 1999 [Ukraine in Polish Eastern Policy in 1989 – 1999]. Poznań. 248 p. [in Polish].

Gedroyts, Y. (2015). Avtobiohrafiya u chotyry ruky [Autobiography in four hands]. Kyiv. 408 p. [in Ukrainian]

Genyk, M. (2006–2007). Vzayemovidnosyny Yezhy Hyedroytsya i ukrayinskoyi emihratsiyi [Relations between Jerzy Giedroyc and Ukrainian emigration]. Halychyna, 12–13, 458–461. [in Ukrainian]

Genyk, M. (2010–2011). Rol “Deklaratsiyi v ukrayinskiy spravi” 1977 roku v dosyahnenni polsko-ukrayinskoho prymyrennya [The role of the Declaration in Ukrainian Affairs in 1977 in achieving Polish-Ukrainian reconciliation]. Ukrayina–Polsha: istorychna spadshchyna i suspilna svidomist, 3–4, 213–221. [in Ukrainian]

Koniuszewski, A. (2012). Meandry geopolityki. Wpływ gry mocarstw na położenie Polski [Geopolitics meanders. Impact of the superpowers' game on Poland's location]. Warszawa. 294 p. [in Polish]

Komar, V. (2011). Kontseptsiya prometeyizmu v politytsi Polshchi (1921 – 1939). [The Concept of Prometheism in the Politics of Poland (1921 – 1939)]. Ivano-Frankivsk. 360 p. [in Ukrainian]

Krasivskyy, O. (2008). Ukrayinsko-polski vzayemyny v 1917 – 1923 rr. [Ukrainian-Polish relations in 1917 – 1923]. Kyiv. 376 p. [in Ukrainian]

Kryvonos, R. (2013). Bek Yuzef [Beck Yousef]. Ukrayinska dyplomatychna entsyklopediya. In 5 vols. Kharkiv, Vol. 1, 245 p. [in Ukrainian]

Lytvyn, M. (Ed.). (2017). Ukrayinsko-polski vidnosyny. Novitnya doba [Ukrainian-Polish relations. The newest day]. Lviv, 732 p. [in Ukrainian]

Myeroshevskyy, U. (2005a). Lysty z ostrova [Letters from the island]. Prostir svobody. Ukrayina na shpaltakh paryzkoyi “Kultury”. Kyiv, 149–156. [in Ukrainian].

Myeroshevskyy, U. (2005b). Rosiyskyy “polskyy kompleks” i prostir ULB [The Russian "Polish Complex" and the Space of the UBL: Article]. Prostir svobody. Ukrayina na shpaltakh paryzkoyi “Kultury”. Kyiv, 195–209. [in Ukrainian]

Nowakowski, J. (1991). Polska polityka wschodnia w 1991 roku. [Polish eastern policy in 1991]. Rocznik Polskiej Polityki Zagranicznej, 77–88. [in Polish]

Pilsudski, J. (1939). Pisma zbiorowe [Collective letters]. Vol. V. Warszawa. 578 p. [in Polish]

Radomski, G. (2000). Narodowa Demokracja wobec problematyki mniejszości narodowych w Drugiej Rzeczypospolitej w latach 1918 – 1926. [National Democracy in the face of the issues of national minorities in the Second Polish Republic in 1918 – 1926]. Toruń. 170 p. [in Polish]

Roszkowski, W. (2009). Najnowsza historia Polski (1914 – 1945) [The latest history of Poland (1914 – 1945)]. Warszawa. 474 p. [in Polish]

Skubiszewski, K. (1997). Polityka zagraniczna i odzyskanie nepodleglosti. Przemówienia, oświadczenia, wywiady 1989 – 1993 [Foreign policy and regaining independence. Speeches, statements, interviews 1989 – 1993]. Warszawa. 756 p. [in Polish]

Strilchuk, L. (2018) The Ukrainian-Polish Confrontation in Volhynia in the Second World War: Historical Memory Transformations. Codrul Cosminului, XXIV (1), 145–165. [in English]

Strilchuk, L. (2008). Ukrayina v polskiy skhidniy politytsi 1989 – 1999 rr. [Ukraine in Polish Eastern Policy 1989 – 1999]. III Mizhnarodnyy naukovy konhres ukrayinskykh istorykiv. «Ukrayinska istorychna nauka na shlyakhu tvorchoho postupu». Lutsk, 17 – 19 travnya 2006 r.: Dopovidi ta povidomlennya. V 3-kh tomakh. Lutsk, T.3. 515–519. [in Ukrainian]

Strilchuk, L. (2013). Ukrayina – Polshcha: vid dobrosusidsʹkykh vidnosyn do stratehichnoho partnerstva (kinets ХХ – ХХІ stolittya) [Ukraine – Poland: from good neighborly relations to strategic partnerships (end of XX – XXI century)]. Lutsk. 608 p. [in Ukrainian]

Suelya, V. (2018). Yuzef Pilsudskyy [Jozef Pilsudski]. Kyiv. 528 p. [in Ukrainian]

Unger, L. (2002). Europa, nie Azja [Europe, not Asia]. Gazeta Wyborcza. 4 lipca. 12. [in Polish]

Wapinski, R. (1989). Roman Dmowski [Roman Dmowski]. Lublin. 392 p. [in Polish]

Wasilewski, L. (1932). O drogi porozumienia [For a way of agreement]. Biuletyń Polsko-Ukraiński, 2, 4–5. [in Polish]

Zashkilnyak, L. O. & Krykun, M. H. (2002). Istoriya Polshchi: Vid naydavnishykh chasiv do nashykh dniv [History of Poland: From ancient times to the present day]. Lviv. 752 p. [in Ukrainian]

Published

2021-03-30

Issue

Section

Articles