THE “MEMORY STUDIES” DEVELOPMENT AND THE HISTORICAL MEMORY DYNAMICS IN INDEPENDENT UKRAINE FROM THE VIEW OF THE MODERN WESTERN HISTORIOGRAPHY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.15.204978Keywords:
historical memory, politics of memory, decolonization, post-colonial dimension, “nationalization” of history, collective memory.Abstract
The purpose of the article is to analyze the historical memory development dynamics, which has a complex, contradictory nature, linked to changes in the government and the corresponding changes in the memory policy, regional and age characteristics of the population. The methodology of the research is based on the theory of scientific knowledge and general philosophical provisions concerning the dialectical interconnection and interdependence of phenomena and processes in society; the specific historical approach and the principles of integrity and objectivity. The article uses primarily the search-bibliographic, historiographic and comparative methods in order to characterize the multifaceted approach of Western scholars concerning the historical memory problems related to the events of World War II. The scientific novelty is that for the first time in the historical science of Ukraine, the most recent English historiography on the historical memory problems in our country concerning the devastating years of World War II has been analyzed from a critical point of view. The Conclusions. Thus, the experience of World War II, which was the greatest tragedy for the peoples of Europe, became the most complex and ambiguous in terms of interpretation. For Ukraine, which was not an independent state at the time, it was more complicated because of the two totalitarian regimes domination: the Communist and the Nazis. The conflicting interpretations of the past, which took place in different regions of Ukraine, were systematically used by politicians during the electoral race, which hindered the creation of a national consensus. Analyzing the historical memory development in modern Ukraine, Western analysts tend to isolate such issues as the collective memory dependence on the regions’ historical path peculiarities, the population’s pre-war and military experience, and changes in the memory politics by the authorities. And these changes in our state were extremely difficult due to the historical science politicization by the ruling elite. The history nationalization, which also took place in Russia, formed the basis for the formation of pro-Soviet historical myths, the “The Great Patriotic War” glorification and, at the same time, the distortion of the Ukrainian experience during 1939 – 1944. The “memory wars” became one of the major causes of the Ukrainian-Russian conflict.References
Babka, V. L. (2016). Istorychna pamiat yak faktor politychnoho vplyvu v nezalezhnii Ukraini [The historical memory as a factor of the political influence in independent Ukraine]. (Candidate’s thesic). Nizhyn, 249 p. [in Ukrainian]
Hrytsenko, O. (2017). Prezydenty i pam’iat. Polityka pam’iati prezydentiv Ukrainy (1994 – 2014): pidgruntia, poslannia, realizatsiia, rezultaty [The Presidents and the memory. the Ukrainian Presidents Memory policy (1994 – 2014): background, message, implementation, results]. Kyiv: K.I.S., 1136 p. [in Ukrainian]
Kasianov, H. (2018). Past continuous: istorychna polityka 1980-kh ‒ 2000-kh. Ukraina ta susidy [Past continuous: historical politics of the 1980-ies – 2000-ies. Ukraine and its neighbors]. Kyiv : Laurus, Antropos-Lohos-Film, 420 p. [in Ukrainian]
Kasianov, H. V. (2016). Istorychna pam’iat ta istorychna polityka: do pytannia pro terminolohiiu y henealohiiu poniat [The historical memory and the historical politics: the question of terminology and genealogy of concepts]. Ukrains’kyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 2, 118–137. [in Ukrainian]
Kasianov, H. V. (2014). Istorychna polityka 1990-kh – poch. ХХI st.: Ukraina ta postradianskyi prostir [The historical Politics of the 1990-ies of the XXIst century: Ukraine and the post-Soviet space]. Ukraina Moderna, 21, 135–159. [in Ukrainian]
Kyrydon, A. (2010). Kolektyvna pamiat v temporalnomu modusi reprezentatsii [The collective memory in the temporal mode of representation]. Kyivska starovyna, 4, 96–105. [in Ukrainian]
Kyrydon, A. (2015). Polityka pam’iati v Ukraini (1991 – 2015 rr.) [Memory Policy in Ukraine (1991 – 2015)]. Ukraina- Ievropa-Svit, (15), 244–250. [in Ukrainian]
Kyrydon, A. (2016). Heterotopii pam’iati: Teoretyko-metodolohichni problemy studii pam’iati [Memory heterotopies: Memory studies theoretical and methodological issues]. Kyiv: Nika-Tsentr, 320 p. [in Ukrainian]
Kyrydon, A. M. (Ed.) (2013). Natsionalna ta istorychna pam’iat: slovnyk kliuchovykh terminiv [National and historical memory: a glossary of key terms]. Kyiv: DP NVTs “Priorytety”, 436 p. [in Ukrainian]
Lysenko, O. Ye. (2015). Podolannia “mifu viiny”, abo Vid yakoi spadshchyny my vidmovliaiemosia: naukovyi dyskurs, polityka pam’iati ta suchasni vyklyky (z pryvodu 70-richchia peremohy nad natsyzmom i fashyzmom) [Overcoming the Myth of War, or What Legacy We Give Up: Scientific Discourse, Memory Policy, and Modern Challenges (About the 70th Anniversary of the Victory over the Nazism and Fascism)]. Ukrains’kyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 2, 4–21. [in Ukrainian]
Nahorna, L. P. (2012). Istorychna pamiat: teorii, dyskursy, refleksii [Historical memory: theories, discourses, reflections]. Kyiv: IPiEND im. I. F. Kurasa, NAN Ukrainy, 328 p. [in Ukrainian]
Rozumnyi, O. M. (2017). Polityka pamiati yak skladova polityky natsionalnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Memory policy as a component of Ukraine’s national security policy] (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Kyiv, 19 p. [in Ukrainian]
Volianiuk, O. Ya. (2013). Konflikty pam’iatei u politychnomu prostori: teoretychni aspekty [Memory conflicts in political space: Theoretical aspects]. (V. F. Soldatenko, ed). Natsionalna ta istorychna pam’iat, (6), 41–54. [in Ukrainian]
Zernii, Yu. O. (2008). Derzhavna polityka pam’iati v Ukraini: stanovlennia ta suchasnyi stan [The public memory policy in Ukraine: formation and current state]. Stratehichni priorytety, 3, 41–51. [in Ukrainian]
Averre, D., & Wolczuk, K. (2016). Introduction: The Ukraine Crisis and Post-Post-Cold War Europe. Europe-Asia studies, 68 (4), 551–555. doi:10.1080/09668136.2016.1176690 [in English]
Bogumił, Z., Wawrzyniak, J., Buchen, T., Ganzer, Chr., Senina, M. (2018). The Enemy on Display: The Second World War in Eastern European Museums. N.Y.; Oxford: Berghahn Books, 190 p. [in English]
Davis, V. (2018). Myth Making in the Soviet Union and Modern Russia: Remembering World War II in Brezhnev’s Hero City. L., N.Y.: I.B. Tauris, 368 p. [in English]
Echternkamp, J. & Jaeger, S. (2019). Introduction: Representing the Second World War in German and European Museums and Memorials. In J. Echternkamp, S. Jaeger (Eds.), Views of Violence.Representing the Second World War in German and European Museums and Memorials (pp. 1–23). N.Y.; Oxford: Berghahn Books. [in English]
Kasianov G. (2015). How a War for the Past Becomes a War in the Present. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 16 (1), 149–156. [in English]
Katchanovski, I. (2010). The Politics of Soviet and Nazi Genocides in Orange Ukraine. Europe-Asia Studies, 62 (6), 973–997. doi: 10.1080/09668136.2010.489265[in English]
Katchanovski, I. (2014). The Politics of World War II in Contemporary Ukraine. The Journal of Slavic Military Studies, 27 (2), 210–233. doi:10.1080/13518046.2013.844493 [in English]
Koposov, N. (2018). Memory Laws, Memory Wars: The Politics of the Past in Europe and Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 328 p. [in English]
Kubik, J. & Bernhard, M. (2014). A Theory of the Politics of Memory. In M. Bernhard, J. Kubik (Eds.). Twenty Years After Communism: The Politics of Memory and Commemoration. (pp. 7–37). NY.: Oxford University Press. [in English]
Kuzio, T. (2016). Soviet and Russian anti-(Ukrainian) nationalism and re-Stalinization. Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 49 (1), 87–99. [in English]
Lehr, J., & Aponiuk N. (2011). Memory, Myth, and Monuments: The Commemoration of a Contested Past in Western Ukraine. Memory Connection, 1 (1), 212–228. [in English]
Macdonald, Sh. (2013). Memorylands: Heritage and Identity in Europe Today. London and N.Y.: Routledge, 320 p. [in English]
Makhortykh, M. (2017). Remediating the past: YouTube and Second World War memory in Ukraine and Russia. Memory Studies. URL: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1750698017730867 [in English]
Munz, P. (1956). History and Myth. The Philosophical Quarterly (Oxford), 6 (22), 1–16. doi: 10.2307/2217333 [in English]
Narvselius, E. (2012). Collective Memories and “Blank Spots” of the Ukrainian Past as Addressed by the Lviv Intellectuals. (B. Törnquist-Plewa & N. Bernsand Eds.) Painful Pasts and Useful Memories. Remembering and Forgetting in Europe. (5) CFE Conference Papers Series, Lund, 51–72. [in English]
Narvselius, E. (2012). The “Bandera Debate”: The contentious legacy of World War II and liberalization of collective memory in Western Ukraine. Canadian Slavonic Papers, 54/3–4, 469–490. doi:10.1080/00085006.2012.11092718[in English]
Narvselius, E. (2012). Ukrainian Intelligentsia in Post-Soviet L’viv: Narratives, Identity, and Power. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books, 412 p. [in English]
Pakier, M. & Wawrzyniak, J. (2015). Introduction: Memory and Change in Eastern Europe: How Special? In M. Pakier, J. Wawrzyniak (Eds) Memory and Change in Europe: Eastern Perspectives (pp. 1–22). N.Y., Oxford: Berghahn Books. [in English]
Penter, T. & Titarenko, D. (2011). Local memory on war, German occupation and postwar years. Cahiers du Monde russe. (Paris), 52/2–3, 475–497. doi:10.4000/monderusse.9348 [in English]
Polegkyi, O. (2015). Identity-building in Post-communist Ukraine: Post-imperial vs Postcolonial Discourses. (B. Törnquist-Plewa, Bernsand N., Narvselius E Eds.). Beyond Transition? Memory and Identity Narratives in Eastern and Central Europe. CFE Conference Papers Series. (7), (pp. 169–190). Lund : Lund University [in English]
Portnov, A. (2013). Memory Wars in Post-Soviet Ukraine (1991 – 2010). In Fedor, J. (Ed.) Memory and Theory in Eastern Europe (pp. 233–254). New York – Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. doi: 10.1057/9781137322067 [in English]
Rudling, P. A. (2013). Memories of “Holodomor” and National Socialism in Ukrainian Political Culture. In Yves Bizeul (Ed.) Rekonstruktion des Nationalmythos?: Frankreich, Deutschland und die Ukraine im Vergleich. (pp. 227–258). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck& Ruprecht Unipress. [in English]
Sakwa, R. (2014). Frontline Ukraine: Crisis in the Borderlands. London: I.B. Tauris & Co Ltd, 220 p. [in English]
Shevel, O. (2016). No Way Out? Post-Soviet Ukraine’s Memory Wars in Comparative Perspective. In H. Hale & R. Orttung (Ed.), Beyond the Euromaidan: Comparative Perspectives on Advancing Reform in Ukraine (pp. 21–40). Stanford California: Stanford University Press. [in English]
Törnquist-Plewa, B. (2016). Cosmopolitan Memory, European Memory and Local Memories in East Central Europe. Australian Humanities Review, 59, 136–154. [in English]
Törnquist-Plewa, B., & Yurchuk, Y. (2019). Memory Politics in Contemporary Ukraine. Reflections from the post-colonial perspective. Memory Studies Journal, 12(6), 1–22. [in English]
Tymkiv, I. M. (2019). Istorychna pamiat: istoriohrafichnyi aspekt fenomenu [Historical memory: the historiographical aspect of the phenomenon ]. URL: http://journals.hnpu.edu.ua/index.php/philosophy/article/view/2100 [in Ukrainian]
Yekelchyk, S. (2011). Bridging the Past and the Future: Ukrainian History Writing Since Independence. Canadian Slavonic Papers. Revue Canadienne des Slavistes, 53 (2–4), 559 – 573. [in English]
Yurchuk, Y. (2012). Nexus Between Cultural Trauma, Collected Memories and Social Trust: a Glass Half-Full, Half-Empty or Shattered. A case of the post-1991 Ukraine. (N. Bernsand & B. Törnquist-Plewa, Eds.) Painful Pasts and Useful Memories, Remembering and forgetting in Europe, (5), 73–90. [in English]
Zhurzhenko, T. (2015). Russia’s never-ending war against “fascism”.Memory politics in the Russian-Ukrainian conflict. URL: https://www.eurozine.com/russias-never-ending-war-against-fascism/ [in English]
