«ORIGINS» OF THE MODERN THEORY OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW IN THE PAPERS OF POLICE LAW SCHOLAR OF THE XIX CENTURY M. KH. BUNGE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.0.184420Keywords:
police law scholar, M.Kh. Bunge, police law, theory of administrative law, state development, state securityAbstract
Summary. The aim of the research. Based on the analysis of the papers of Mykola Khrystyianovych Bunge and comparison of their provisions with modern scientific professional sources, the paper substantiates the «basic» (fundamental) role of «theory of police law» («police theory») formulated by the prominent police law scholar in the XIX century for the contemporary domestic theory of administrative law. Research methodology is grounded on the principles of historical, comparative analysis. Scientific novelty is defined by the fact that it is proposed an innovative approach to the analysis of the provisions of M. Kh. Bunge’s papers in the aspect of the comparison of their provisions with the content of the modern scientific sources directly devoted to the priorities of the formation of the contemporary doctrine of administrative law which results in the substantiation of «basic» role of the scientific heritage of police law scholar of the XIX century M. Kh. Bunge for the latter. Conclusions. Thus, a detailed analysis of M. Kh. Bunge’s scientific papers directly devoted to «police law» shows that basic principles of the modern theory of administrative law were formed in the XIX century, in particular regarding the comprehension of administrative law, its methods (with the separation of the specific nature of resource of each of them), major institutes and its system as a whole, sources and priorities for their formation. Consequently, it necessitates the intensification of comparative legal studies of the scientific heritage of the XIX century which not only keeps its role but also strengthens it through the years. However, the later should be consistent, detailed, system-based, and the use of historical professional source – correct and justified. Under such circumstance, it is possible to maximize the use of that unique resource of scientific sources on the subject of «theory of police law» («police theory»), which practically serves as a basis for the modern domestic theory of administrative law despite the period of its formation.
References
Rymarenko, Yu. I., Averianov, V. B., Usenko, I. B. (2003). Antolohiia ukrainskoi yurydychnoi dumky. Tom 5: Politseiske ta administratyvne pravo [Anthology of Ukrainian legal thought. Volume 5 : Police and administrative law]. Kyiv: InYure, 600 р. [in Ukrainian]
Shemshuchenko, Yu. S. (ed.). (1998). Yurydychna entsyklopediia [Legal encyclopedia]. Kyiv, 490 р. [in Ukrainian]
Kolomoiets, T. O., Klopakova, V. K. (ed.). (2013). Administratyvno-pravova osvita u personaliiakh [Administrative-legal education in personalities]. Kyiv: InYure, 325 р. [in Ukrainian]
Skopenko, V. V., Korotkyi, V. A., Tabenska, T. V., Tyshchenko, I. I., & Shevchenko, L. V. (2006). Rektory Kyivskoho universytetu 1834 – 2006 [Rectors of Kyiv University 1834 – 2006]. Kyiv: Lybid, 336 р. [in Ukrainian]
Politseiske pravo. (2010). Politseiske pravo v Universyteti Sviatoho Volodymyra [Police law in St. Volodymyr University]. Kyiv: Lybid, 464 р. [in Ukrainian]
Korniichuk, L. Ya. (2005). M.Kh. Bunhe – zasnovnyk Kyivskoi psykholohichnoi shkoly politychnoi ekonomii [M. Kh. Bunge – afounder of Kyiv psychological school of political economy]. M. Kh. Bunhe: suchasnyi dyskurs [M. Kh. Bunge: modern discourse] (pp. 56–69). Kyiv: Znannia. [in Ukrainian]
Kolomoets, T. A. (2018). Issledovanie naslediia Nikolaia Khristianovicha Bunhe i ego vliianiia na formirovanie sovremennoi administrativnoi nauki i yuridycheskoho obrazovaniia v Ukraine (k 195-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia) [Study of the heritage of Nikolay Khristianovich Bunge and his influence on the modern science of administrative law and legal education formation (on the occasion of the 195th birth anniversary)]. Admynistrativnoe pravo i protsess, 1, 52–58. [in Russian]
Romnin, O. (2003). Idealnyi profesor. Do 180-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia Mykoly Khrystyianovycha Bunhe (1823 – 1895), ekonomist, pravoznavets, profesor i derzhavnyi diiach, rektor Kyivskoho universytetu iz 1859 po 1880 rik [Ideal professor. On the occasion of 180th birth anniversary of Mykola Khrystyianovych Bunge (1823 – 1895), economist, legal scholar, professor, government leader, Rector of Kyiv University from 1859 till 1880]. Dzerkalo tyzhnia, 44, 22. [in Ukrainian]
Stepanov, V. L. (1998). N. Kh. Bunhe: sudba reformatora [N. Kh. Bunge: reformer destiny]. Moscow: Rossyiskaia politicheskaia entsyklopediia, 398 р. [in Russian]
Buriachok, O. (2012). Henezys suchasnykh naukovykh doslidzhen, prysviachenykh derzhavno-pravovym pohliadam M.Kh. Bunhe [The genesis of the modern scholarly research devoted to the M.Kh. Bunge`s state-legal views]. Pidpryiemnytstvo, hospodarstvo i pravo, 4, 114–117. [in Ukrainian]
Hrytsenko, I. S., Melnyk, R. S., Pukhtetska, A. A. (etc.) (2015). Zahalne administratyvne pravo [General administrative law]. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 568 р. [in Ukrainian]
Yurydychnyi fakultet (2015). Yurydychnyi fakultet Universytetu Sv. Volodymyra v personaliiakh yoho vykladachiv ta vchenykh, prysviachena 140-richchiu vid dnia narodzhennia rektora Ye.V. Spektorskoho [Law Faculty of the St. Volodymyr University in the personalities of its lecturers and scholars devoted to the 140th birth anniversary of Rector Ye.V. Spektorskyi. Conference abstracts]. Kyiv: Kyivskyi natsionalnyi universytet imeni Tarasa Shevchenka, 18 р. [in Ukrainian]
Hrytsenko, I.S. (2009). Yurydychnyi fakultet Universytetu Sviatoho Volodymyra, 1834 – 1920 [Law Faculty of the St. Volodymyr University, 1834 – 1920]. Kyiv: Lybid, 256 р. [in Ukrainian]
Kolomoiets, T.O. (2011). Administratyvne pravo. Akademichnyi kurs [Administrative law. Academic course]. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 576 р. [in Ukrainian].
Strelchenko, O.H. (2008). Zaokhochennia yak metod upravlinnia u sferi okhorony zdorovia [The insentives as a method of management in health care]. (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Kyiv, 19 р. [inUkrainian].
Kolomoiets, T., Stetsenko, V., & Kushnir, S. (2018). Bonus for a public servant – is it scheduled raise to official salary or effective method for motivation? there should be regulatory «filters» for its use. Baltic journal of Economic studies, 4 (4), 173–180. [in English].
