The purpose of the research – is to demonstrate the heated discussion in the Polish historiography concerning the ancient Poland state system issues in the context of the modern typology of the scientific conflicts. The methodology of the research is based on the general scientific and special historical methods application. The principles of historicism, the objectivity and the value approach concerning the studied phenomena have been observed. The study source base has been covered and ensured by the heuristic method application. The use of the historical-genetic, historical-typological and historical-systemic methods has made it possible to reproduce and follow precisely the scientific discussions unfolding and to obtain the correct conclusions. The scientific novelty is that for the first time in historiography, the scientific controversy in the beginning of the XXth century concerning the state system of the ancient Polish state, which was developed between the scientists O. Balcer and S. Kutrzeba and was supported by other researchers, is regarded as a worldview controversy of the numerous historiographic centers and generations representatives. Conclusions. The essence of the scientific conflict between the researchers O. Balcer and S. Kutrzeba consisted in the theoretical and methodological aspects, as it arose because of the conceptual differences within the classical positivist model of historiography that at the beginning of the XXth century stepped into the phase of the modernist transformations. As far as we are concerned, such conflicts have rarely a destructive nature, but rather contribute to the fruitful competition of ideas, since «the minimum level presence competition creates the conditions for the new ideas birth» (Collins, 2002). Therefore, it is undisputed that the above-mentioned controversy contributed to the further scientific progress significantly, as it inspired scientists to study the ancient Polish state nature more thoroughly, as well as raised the new issues, revised many fundamental problems, and even led to the introduction of new numerous views into the historical science in the participantsʼ publications.

Ключові слова

Polish historiography, historical legal research, scientific discussion, scientific conflict


Adamus, J. (1933). Oswald Balzer [Oswald Balzer]. Przegląd prawa i administracji, 1–7.

Adamus, J. (1958). Polska teoria rodowa [Polish family theory]. Łódź: Wyd. Zakładu Narodowego im. Ossolińskich we Wroċławiu, 348 s.

Balcer, O. (1906). Z powodu nowego zarysu historii ustroju Polski [About the new outline of the history of the Polish political system]. Kwartalnik Historyczny, 20, 1–58, 397–441.

Balcer, O. (1907). Państwo polskie w pierwszem siedmdziesięcioleciu XIV i XV wieku [Polish state in the first seventy years of the XIV and XV centuries]. Kwartalnik Historyczny, 21, 193–291.

Balcer, O. (1916). Stolice Polski 963 1138 [Polish capitals 963 – 1138]. Lwów: Wyd. Towarzystwa dla Popierania Nauki Polskiej, 74 s.

Balcer, O. (1919 – 1920). Królestwo polskie 1295 1370 [Polish Kingdom 1295 – 1370]. Lwów: Wyd. Towarzystwa dla Popierania Nauki Polskiej. T. VI, 448 s.; T. VII, 536 s.; T. VIII, 364 s. [in Polish].

Baranec, N., Verevkin, A., & Savinova, L. (2012). O prichinah nauchnyh konfliktov [About the causes of our conflicts]. Vlast': Obshhenacional'nyj nauchno-politicheskij zhurnal, 4, 115. [in Russian].

Bardach, J. (1957). Historia państwa i prawa Polski do polowy XV wieku [The history of the state and Polish law until the mid-XVth century]. Warszawa: PWN, 592 s. [in Polish].

Biliński, P. (2011). Stanisław Kutrzeba (1876 1946). Biografia naukowa i polityczna [Stanisław Kutrzeba (1876 – 1946). Scientific and political biography]. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, 236 s. [in Polish].

Kętrzyński, S. (1909). O królestwie wielkopolskim [About the Kingdom of Vielkopolska]. Przegląd Historyczny, VIII, 129–153. [in Polish].

Kolbuszewska, J. (2005). Mutacja modernistyczna w historiografii polskiej (przełom XIX i XX wieku) [The modernist mutation in Polish historiography (turn of the 19th and 20th century)]. Łódź: Ibidem, 253 s. [in Polish].

Kollinz, R. (2002). Piraty i politiki v matematike [Pirates and politics in a matematike]. Otechestvennye zapiski, 7. URL: http: // (28.01.2018 p.) [in Polish].

Krzyżanowski, S. (1909). Regnum Poloniae [Regnum Poloniae]. Sprawozdania AU, Kraków, 5. [in Polish].

Krzyżanowski, S. (1913). ). Regnum Poloniae [Regnum Poloniae]. Sprawozdania AU, Kraków, 9. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1900). Finanse Krakowa w wiekach średnich [Cracov's finances in the Middle Ages]. Rocznik Krakowski, 3, 1–145. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1902). Handel Krakowa w wiekach średnich na tle stosunków handlowych Polski [Cracov`s trade in the Middle Ages against the background of Poland's trade relations]. Kraków: Nakładem Akademii Umiejętności, 196 s. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1902). Sądy ziemskie i grodzkie w wiekach średnich [The land and the town courts in the Middle Ages]. Kraków: Nakładem Akademii Umiejętności, 123 s. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1905). Historya ustroju Polski w zarysie [An outline of the history of the Polish political system]. Lwów, 261 s. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1906). Kilka kwestii z historyi ustroju Polski. Przyczynki i polemika [A few issues from the history of the Polish political system. Facts and polemics]. Kwartalnik Historyczny, 20, 589–626. [in Polish].

Kutrzeba, S. (1914). Historia ustroju Polski w zarysie. Tom 2: Litwa [An outline of the history of the Polish political system. Volume 2: Lithuania]. Lwów-Warszawa, 241 s. [in Polish].

Łodyński, M. (1914). Regnum Poloniae w opinii publicznej XIV [Regnum Poloniae in public opinion XIV]. Kwartalnik Historyczny, 28, 38–54. [in Polish].

Maternicki, J. (1982). Historiografia polska XX wieku. Cz. 1. Lata 1900 1918 [XXth century Polish historiography. Vol. 1. The years 1900 – 1918]. Wrocław : Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich-Wydawnictwo, 246 s. [in Polish].

Nowacki, R. (1998). Oswald Balzer (1858 – 1933) [Oswald Balzer (1858 – 1933)]. Opole: Wyd. Uniwersytetu Opolskiego, 314 s. [in Polish].

Oswald Balzer i lwowska szkoła historycznoprawna (2010) [Oswald Balzer and Lviv historical law school]. (ed. M. Masłowska). Lublin: Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski, 406 s. [in Polish].

Polaczkówna, H. (1933). Oswald Marjan Balzer [Oswald Marjan Balzer]. Archion. Warszawa, XI, 7–19. [in Polish].

Polemika (1907). Kutszeba S. – Balzer O. [Polemics. Kutszeba S. – Balzer O.] Kwartalnik Historyczny, 21, 587–590. [in Polish].

Tymieniecki, K. (1920). Odnowienie dawnego Królewstwa polskiego [The renewal of the former Polish Kingdom]. Kwartalnik Historyczny, 34, 30–87. [in Polish].

Wojciechowski, Z. (1926). Oswald Balzer jako historyk ustroju Polski [Oswald Balzer as a historian of the Polish political system]. Poznań, 25 s.

Zajączkowski, S. (1933) Ś. p. Prof. Oswald Balzer [Ś. p. Prof. Oswald Balzer]. Ateneum Wileńskie, IX, 436–442. [in Polish].

Пристатейна бібліографія ГОСТ

ISSN 2519-058X (Print) ISSN 2664-2735 (Online)