HISTORICAL MEMORY ABOUT SECOND WORLD WAR IN THE CONTEXT OF THREATS OF GOVERNMENT IN UKRAINE

Authors

  • Yurii NIKOLAIETS Doctor of Historical Sciences, Full Professor, Leading Researcherof Department of National Minorities Institute of Political and ethno-national studies named after I. F. Kuras of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.11.170716

Keywords:

historical memory, Ukraine, the Second World war, hybrid war, the policy of memory

Abstract

The aim of the research the character of the Second World war historical memory formation in Ukrainian society and its influence on the process of the state building in Ukraine was determined. The research methodology is based on the principles of historicism, the objectivity of systematic, scientific, as well as the use of general scientific (analysis, synthesis, scientific abstraction) and special-historical (historical-genetic, historical-typological, historical-system) methods and methods of political science (behavioral, cultural, anthropological). The scientific novelty is that for the first time in Ukrainian historiography, on the basis of analysis of the content of scientific and individual journalistic publications, the means of forming historical memory of the Second World War in Ukrainian society are determined, the influence of formation of such historical memory on the process of modern Ukrainian state formation is determined. Conclusions. On the eve of and during the Second World War, the attainment of the goals by the belligerent parties involved massive manipulation of ethnic values, historical memory. Founded on the basis of mobilization of people in the war, such manipulations inevitably influenced the nature of the organization of propaganda campaigns, and eventually and coverage of the researchers of the events of the war. Formed predominantly in the winner’s camp, the results of manipulations by the consciousness of citizens for a long time «traveled» with scientific works in the form of dies. Their generation was most often driven by ideas about civil obligations, the assessment of the goals and nature of the fighting and the role of individual countries in its rebellion, as well as the allied relations between the countries participating in the war. In view of this, the assessments of the Ukrainian population’s participation in the Second World War were largely conditioned by the inclusion of its lands in different states (and, consequently, the difference in the assessment of civil obligations), the change in the alliance's priorities of the USSR and Germany during the war and the specifics of the views of senior management It is these states about the goals and objectives of ethnopolitics. The policy of memory of the Second World War until recently was used by the Russian Federation as an obstacle to the development of Ukrainian statehood, as well as a means of mobilizing part of Russian citizens to conduct hostilities in Ukraine. In addition, in Ukraine, the memory of the war as a tragedy of mankind, which must be avoided in the future, is being formed.

Reforming the policy of memory in relation to the Second World War in Ukraine is taking place in the framework of European integration and integration into the world community. Instead, in Russia, the policy of memory is increasingly associated with the sacrifice of Victory, with the simultaneous rejection of any alternative assessments of events of the time that was characteristic of the Soviet Union. Ukraine gradually departs from the Soviet modeling of historical memory of the Second World War. Instead, the RF is actively using manipulations with historical memory to strengthen its position in the informational confrontation with Ukraine and to unite its own people around the idea of «Russian peace».

References

Butenko, Ye. (2010). V «donetskom» dele Bandery segodnya postavit tochku Vysshiy adminsud [In the «Donetsk» Bandera case the end would be put today at the High Administrative Court]. URL: http://www.salon.donetsk.ua/rubrics/11886.php [in Russian].

Chervonenko, V. & Khomenko, S. (2019). Avtokefaliya, banderovtsy i ssory s zhurnalistami: kak Yepifaniyu dali Tomos [Autocephaly, Bandera and quarrels with journalists: how Epiphanius was given by Tomos]. URL: https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/features-russian-46780864 [in Russian].

Deyton, L. (2000). Vtoraya mirovaya: oshibki, promakhi, poteri [The Second World war: mistakes, misses and loses]. Moskva: Eksmo-Press, 688 p. [in Russian].

Dmitrievskiy, A. (2013). Durman natsionalisticheskikh illyuziy [Datura of nationalistic illusions]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 12–18 maya. [in Russian].

Doklad MID Rossii. Neonatsizm – opasnyy vyzov pravam cheloveka, demokratii i verkhovenstvu prava [Neo-Nazism is a dangerous challenge to human rights, democracy and the rule of law]. URL: http://www.mid.ru/diverse/-/asset_publisher/8bWtTfQKqtaS/content/id/1278647 [in Russian].

Dubovoy, G. (2010). Ukraintsy szhigayut pasporta [Ukrainians burn passports]. URL: http://www.salon.donetsk.ua/rubrics/11053.php [in Russian].

Federalnyy zakon O vnesenii izmeneniy v otdelnye zakonodatelnye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii, 05.05.2014, № 128-FZ [On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation, 05.05.2014, № 128-FZ]. URL: http://kremlin.ru/acts / bank / 38395 [in Russian].

Gordeeva, L. (2010). Garanta s Banderoy – k sudu! [Warranty with Bandera – to court!]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 2 maya. [in Russian].

Gordeeva, L. (2013). Fashizm na Ukraine: ugroza ili realnost [Fascism in Ukraine: threat or reality]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 26 iyunya 04 iyulya. [in Russian].

Gribenko, Ye. (1989). Narodnoe dvizhenie Luganshchiny [Popular movement of Lugansk region]. Voroshilovgradskaya pravda – The truth of Voroshilovgrad, 2 dekabrya. [in Russian].

Gulevich, V. (2016). Ukraina: neonatsizm vmesto istoricheskoy pamyati [Ukraine: neo-Nazism instead of historical memory]. URL: https://odnarodyna.org/content/ukraina-neonacizm-vmesto-istoricheskoy-pamyati [in Russian].

Horbulyn, V. P., Vlasiuk, O. S. & Kononenko, S. V. (2015). Ukraina i Rosiia: dev’iatyi val chy kytaiska stina [Ukraine and Russia: the ninth shaft or the Chinese wall]. Kyiv: NISD, 132 p. [in Ukrainian].

Hrynevych, V. (1992). UPA i Chervona Armiia, Ukrainska Povstanska Armiia i natsionalno-vyzvolna borotba v Ukraini u 1940 – 1950-kh rr. [UPA and the Red Army, Ukrainian Insurgent Army and national liberation struggle in Ukraine in the 1940 – 1950’s.]. Materialy Vseukrainskoi naukovoi konferentsii, 25–26 serpnia, (pp 194–200). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].

Hrynevych, V. (1994). Natsionalni problemy v Chervonii Armii v period vyzvolennia Ukrainy vid nimetsko-fashystskykh zaharbnykiv (hruden 1942–zhovten 1944 pr.) [National problems in the Red Army during the liberation of Ukraine from the Nazi invaders (December 1942 – October 1944)] (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Kyiv, 16 p. [in Ukrainian].

Hunchak, T. (2011). Kliuchovi problemy istoriohrafii u Druhii svitovii viini [Key Problems of Historiography in the Second World War]. Kyiv: Ukrainska vydavnycha spilka im. Yu. Lypy, 225 p. [in Ukrainian].

Ivanov, A. & Romanko, O. (2013). Otnoshenie k kolaboratsionizmu – svidetelstvo tsivilizatsionnogo raskola Ukrainy [Attitude towards collaborationism - evidence of the civilizational split of Ukraine]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk , 10–16 maya. [in Russian].

Ivanov, A. (2010a). Bandero-evropeyskaya nesovmestimost [Bandero-European incompatibility]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 5 noyabrya. [in Russian].

Ivanov, A. (2010b). Nikotin natsionalizma i Tabachnik [Nicotine Nationalism and Tabachnik]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 19–25 marta. URL: http://www.odnako.org/blogs/nikotin-nacionalizma-i-tabachnik/comments/page-2/#70136 [in Russian].

Kissindzher, H. (2017). Svitovyi poriadok. Rozdumy pro kharakter natsii v istorychnomu konteksti [The world order. Reflections on the nature of nations in the historical context]. Kyiv: Nash format, 320 p. [in Ukrainian].

Kornilov, V. (2013). Fashistskaya «ukrainizatsiya» Donbassa: po materialam okkupatsionnoy pressy [Fascist «Ukrainization» of Donbass: on the materials of the occupation press]. URL: http://kornilov.name/fashistskaya-ukrainizatsiya-donbassa-po-materialam-okkupatsionnoy-pressyi/ [in Russian].

Lysenko, O. Ye. (2011). Istoriopysannia Druhoi svitovoi viiny yak samostiina subdystsyplina [Historical descriptions of the Second World War as an independent subdiscipline]. In V. A. Smolii (Ed.), Ukraina v Druhii svitovii viini: pohliad z XXI st. (Vol. 1, pp. 9–42). Kyiv: Naukova dumka. [in Ukrainian].

Marchenko, T. (2010). Donbassu vygodna provintsialnost [Donbas profitable provincialism]. URL: http://www.salon.donetsk.ua/rubrics/12044.php [in Russian].

Masnenko, V. V. (2002). Istorychna pam’iat yak osnova formuvannia natsionalnoi svidomosti [Historical memory as the basis for the formation of national consciousness]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnalUkrainian Historical Journal, 5, 49–62. [in Ukrainian].

Messendzher, Ch. (1957). Entsiklopediya voyn XX veka [The encyclopedia of the XX century wars]. Moskva: Eksmo-Press, 520 p. [in Russian].

Mikhaylova, Ye. (2013a). Volyn: krovavoe leto 1943-go i demagogiya 2013 goda [Volyn: the bloody summer of 1943 and the demagogy of 2013]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 26 iyulya – avgusta. [in Russian].

Mikhaylova, Ye. (2013b). Internatsionalist protiv neofashistov [Internationalist vs neo-fascists]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 21–2 iyunya. [in Russian].

Mints, M. (Ed.). (2011). Nachalo Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny: sovremennaya istoriografiya: sbornik obzorov i referatov [The beginning of the Great Patriotic War: modern historiography: Digest of reviews and articles]. Moskva: Tsentr sotsialno naucho-informatsionnykh issledovaniy; otdel istorii, 160 p. [in Russian].

Na vostoke voyuyut russkie neonatsisty [In the east, Russian neo-Nazis are fighting]. URL: http://hadashot.kiev.ua/content/na-vostoke-voyuyut-russkie-neonacisty [in Russian].

Nikolaiets, Yu. O. (1997). Dezertyrstvo iz lav Chervonoi Armii v Ukraini na pochatkovykh etapakh Velykoi Vitchyznianoi viiny [Desertion from the rocks of the Red Army in Ukraine at the initial stages of the Great Patriotic War]. Z arkhiviv VUChK, HPU, NKVD, KHB – From the archives of The All-Russian emergency commission, The Governmental Political Administration, The National Commissariat of Internal Relations, The Committee of Governmental Security Control, 1–2, 169–175. [in Ukrainian].

Nikolaiets, Yu. O. (1998). Moralnyi stan Chervonoi Armii v Ukraini v pershyi period viiny proty nimetsko-fashystskykh zaharbnykiv. Dezertyrstvo ta borotba z nym [The mental state of solders of the Red Army in Ukraine in the wars 1st period against German-Fascist invaders ]. Kyiv: Mizhnarodna finansova ahentsiia, 61 p. [in Ukrainian].

Nikolaiets, Yu. O. (2004). Moralno-politychnyi stan naselennia Ukrainy u pershyi period Velykoi Vitchyznianoi viiny [Moral-political status of the population of Ukraine in the first period of the Great Patriotic War]. Vinnytsia: Kh-ART, 334 p. [in Ukrainian].

Nora, P. (1999). Problematika mest pamyati. [Problems of memory]. Frantsiya-pamyat (pp. 17–50). Sankt-Peterburg: Izdatelstvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. [in Russian].

Nora, P. (2010). Istoriki ponyali, chto zakony – ochen opasnaya veshch [Historians understand that laws are a very dangerous thing]. URL: http://urokiistorii.ru/article/1049 [in Russian].

Pogransluzhba Ukrainy obnarodovala khronologiyu nepravomernykh deystviy rossiyskoy storony v Krymu [The Frontier Service of Ukraine published a chronology of illegal actions of the Russian side in the Crimea]. URL: http://zn.ua/UKRAINE/pogransluzhba-ukrainy-obnarodovala-hronologiyu-nepravomernyh-deystviy-rossiyskoy-storony-v-krymu-140230_.html [in Russian].

Polskiy shlagbaum dlya lvovskikh banderovtsev [Polish barrier for Lviv Bandera]. URL: http://dkr.com.ua/index.php?new=13336 [in Russian].

Poskrebyshev, V. (2013). Fashizm pora ostanovit! [Fascism is time to stop!]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 14–20 iyunya. [in Russian].

Pro doktrynu informatsiinoi bezpeky Ukrainy. Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrainy vid 8 lypnia 2009 r. № 514/2009 [About the doctrine of information security of Ukraine. The decree of the President of Ukraine from 2009 № 514/2009]. URL: http://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/514/2009 [in Ukrainian].

Semenov, I. (2014). Vykhod iz krymskoy lovushki [Out of the Crimean trap]. URL: http://glavcom.ua/articles/18018.html [in Russian].

Semenov, S. (2013). My i sosedi v zerkale kontrastov [We and the neighbors in the mirror of contrasts]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 5–11 aprelya. [in Russian].

Senyavskiy, A. S. & Senyavskaya, Ye. S. (2009). Vtoraya mirovaya voyna istoricheskaya pamyat: obraz proshlogo v kontekste sovremennoy geopolitiki [World War II and historical memory: the image of the past in the context of modern geopolitics]. Vestnik MGIMO. Spetsialnyy vypusk – Messenger of Moskow State Institute of International Relations. Special edition, 299–310. [in Russian].

Snayder, T. (2017). Tselyu Vtoroy mirovoy voyny, s tochki zreniya Gitlera, byl zakhvat Ukrainy [The purpose of the Second World War, in terms of Hitler, was the seizure of Ukraine URL: https://fakty.ua/240338-timoti-snajder-celyu-vtoroj-mirovoj-vojny-s-tochki-zreniya-gitlera-byl-zahvat-ukrainy [in Russian].

Sosnina, I. (n. d.) MID RF nazval «stiraniem istoricheskogo proshlogo» okonchatelnuyu otmenu «Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny» v Ukraine [Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs called the «abolition of the historical past» the definitive abolition of the «Great Patriotic War» in Ukraine]. URL: https://kp.ua/politics/592480-myd-rf-nazval-styranyem-ystorycheskoho-proshloho-okonchatelnuui-otmenu-velykoi-otechestvennoi-voiny-v-ukrayne [in Russian].

Sychev, I. (2013). Vragi Pobedy i ikh pokroviteli [Enemies of Victory and their patrons]. Donetskiy kryazh – Ridge of Donetsk, 17–23 maya. [in Russian].

Tishkov, V. (2007). Russkiy mir: smysl i strategii [Russian Peace: Meaning and Strategies]. URL: http://sr.fondedin.ru/new/fullnews_arch_to.php?archive=1185275035&id=1185274651&subaction=showfull [in Russian].

Verkhovna Rada zrivniala u pravakh biitsiv OUN-UPA z uchasnykamy boiovykh dii [Ukrainian Law, The Verkhovna Rada has equalled the rights of fighters of the OUN-UPA with the combatants]. URL: https://nv.ua/ukr/ukraine/politics/verkhovna-rada-zrivnjala-u-pravakh-bijtsiv-oun-upa-z-uchasnikami-bojovikh-dij-2511849.html [in Ukrainian].

Vert, A. (1967). Rossiya v voyne 1941 1945 gg. [Russia in the war of 1941 1945]. Moskow: Progress, 774 p. [in Russian].

Zelmayer. (1957). Mirovaya voyna 1939 1945 [World war 1939 1945] (pp. 122–132). Moskva: Izdatelstvo inostranoy literatury. [in Russian].

Zhmakyna, Yu. (2008). Prezydent Ukrainy zasterihaie: informatsiina ekspansiia inozemnykh derzhav ye naibilshoiu zahrozoiu natsionalnii bezpetsi Ukrainy [The President of Ukraine warns: information expansion of foreign countries is the greatest threat to the national security of Ukraine]. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/1113131.html [in Ukrainian].

Zubov, A. B. (2009). Istoriya Rossii. XX vek. 1894 1939 [The history of Russia in the XX century. 1894 – 1939]. Moskva: Astrel, 829 p. [in Russian].

Downloads

Issue

Section

Articles