POLICY OF TCARISM AND SOVIET LEADERSHIP CONCERNING THE ETHNIC GERMANS DURING THE FIRST AND THE SECOND WORLD WAR
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.10.159175Keywords:
ethnic Germans, «Volksdeutsche», anti-German campaign, war policy, World War I, World War II.Abstract
The publication's purpose. The goal of the research is to study the policies of the imperial and Soviet leadership regarding ethnic Germans in the period of the First and Second World Wars and to conduct their comparative analysis. The methodology of work is based on the principles of historicism, systemic, scientific, objectivity, as well as on the use of general scientific and special-historical methods and on the theoretical basis of modern historiography, according to which First and Second World War are considered as two phases of one historical event. This approach opens up the new opportunities for researchers, both in generating ideas, and in the context of the factual reproduction of the past war. The scientific novelty lies in the fact that for the first time in historiography there was made the search for historical parallels between anti-German campaigns concerning the civilian population that took place in two world wars. This allowed us to illustrate the inadmissibility of collective allegations in collaboration based on the ethnic grounds. Conclusions. Numerous deportations of ethnic Germans in 1915 were due to the declarative goals – to prevent the entry of ethnic Germans into the armies of the enemy during the withdrawal of the imperial army. The greatest difference of the policy of the «German issue» in 1914 – 1915 between the policy of 1941 – 1942 was that the actions of the imperial government directly have depended on the military failures of the Russian army. Until the beginning of the Second World War, the victims of repressions except the Germans were also Ukrainians, Russians, Poles and others peoples; officially this side of repression was not being propagated by the authorities. Close to 1941, such repressive actions had a class character. Deportation of the German population during the Second World War was of a purely ethnic character and was carried out as a preventive measure. Only the Soviet security forces in the peacetime resorted to restrictions on the right to life and to direct physical destruction of ethnic Germans. It is noted that the fear of tsarism and Soviet leadership before the fifth column during the war years has played a decisive role in the fate of the German ethnic minority. It is emphasized that in the extraordinary circumstances (war, occupation, the policy of total unification of non-indigenous nations) the ruling government tends to practice the use of the ethnic image of the enemy. Therefore, there is quite logical rhetorical question: who they are – the German colonists, the German refugees, the German special settlers and the Ukrainian «Volksdeutsche», if not «their own» convenient enemies?
References
Beznosov, A.Y`. (2001). Mennonity Yuga Ukrainy v gody «velikoho pereloma» (1928–1930) [Mennonites of South of Ukraine in the years of «great break» (1928 – 1930)]. Otv. red. Bobuleva S.J. Voprosрy germanskoj istoriyi: sbornik nauchnyh trudov. Dnipropetrovsk: DNU, 75–90. [in Ukrainian].
Bovua, D. (1998). Bytva za zemlju v Ukrajini. 1863 – 1914: Poljaky v socio-etnichnykh konfliktakh [A battle is for earth in Ukraine. 1863 – 1914: Poland in social-ethnicх conflicts]. Kyiv: Krytyka, 334 s. [in Ukrainian].
Brusіlov, A. Y. (2002). Moy vospomynanyja [My remembrances]. Minsk: Kharpeet, 432 s. [inBelarus].
Vasyljchuk, V. M. (2001). Nimecjki poselenci v Ukrajinian u pershyj period Radjansjkoji vlady [The German settlers are in Ukraine in a first period of Soviet power]. Voprosi ghermanskoj istoriyi: sbornyk nauchnikh trudov. Otv. red. Bobyleva S.J. Dnipropetrovsjk: DNU, 22–41. [in Ukrainian].
Gherman, A. A. (1999). Antinemeckie kampanii [AntyGerman campaigns]. Nemcи Rossiy: еncyklopedіja T.1. Red. V. Karev. Moskva: ERN, 62–64. [in Russian].
Kryvec, N. V. (1998). Deportacyja nemcev s Ukrayny v 1930-kh – nachale 1940-kh gg. [Deportation of Germans from Ukraine in 1930 – beginning of 1940th гг]. Myghracyonnue processu sredy rossyjskykh nemcev: ystorycheskyj aspekt: materyalu mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencyy (267–272). Anapa. [in Russian].
Lozinsjka, I. (2017). Orghanizacija rosijsjkogho cyviljnogho upravlinnja u Ghalychyni (serpenj – veresenj 1914 roku) [Organization of the Russian civil management is in Galychina (August is September, 1914)]. Skhidnojevropejsjkyj istorychnyj visnyk, 2, 21–30. doi: https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.2.101456 [in Ukrainian].
Lor, Je. (2012). Russkyj nacyonalyzm y Rossyjskaja ymperyja: Kampanyja protyv «vrazheskykh poddannukh» v ghodu Pervoj myrovoj vojnu [Russian nationalism and Russian empire: Campaign against «hostile nationals» in the years of First world war]. Moskva: Novoe lіteraturnoe obozrenye, 304 р. [in Russian].
Nelypovych, S. Gh. (1997). Nemeckuju pakostj uvolytj y bez nezhnostej…[To discharge the German dirty trick and without soft things]. Voenno-ystorycheskyj zhurnal, 1, 42–51. [in Russian].
Nikoljskyj, V. M. (2001). Represiji orghaniv derzhavnoji bezpeky shhodo nimciv Ukrajiny u 1937 r.: kiljkisni pokaznyky. Otv. red. Bobuleva S.J. Voprosu ghermanskoj ystoryy: sbornyk nauchnukh trudov [Repressions of organs of state security in relation to Germans of Ukraine in 1937: quantitative indexes]. Dnipropetrovsjk: DNU, 51–62. [in Ukrainian].
Sukhoverska, I. (2018). Problemy traktuvannja kolaboryzmu v roky drughoji svitovoji vijny u suchasnij rosijsjkij istorioghrafiji [Problems of interpretation of coloboruzmya are in the years of the second world war in modern Russian historiography]. Skhidnojevropejsjkyj istorychnyj visnyk, 6, 147–155. doi: https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.6.125199. [in Ukrainian].
Khaghen, fon M. (1999). Velykaja vojna y yskusstvennoe usylenye эtnycheskogho samosoznanyja v Rossyjskoj ymperyy [Great war and artificial strengthening of ethnic consciousness are in the Russian empire]. Rossyja y Pervaja myrovaja vojna (materials of the international scientific colloquium) (рр. 385–405).St. Petersburg. [in Russian].
Centraljnyj derzhavnyj istorychnyj arkhiv Ukrajiny [CSHAUK – Central state historical archive ofUkraine, Kyiv] [in Ukrainian].
Shevchuk, N. A. (1996). O probleme «myrnogho zavoevanyja» Jugha Ukraynи nemeckymy kolonystamy [About the problem of «peaceful conquest» of South of Ukraine by the German colonists]. Voprosu ghermanskoj ystoruy: sbornyk nauchnukh trudov. Ed. Bobyleva S.J. Dnipropetrovsjk: DNU, 48–56. [in Ukrainian].
