UKRAINIAN COSSACKS IN THE BATTLE OF TSETSORA AND THE KHOTYN WAR IN SCIENTIFIC WORKS OF JÓZEF SZUJSKI
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.9.150369Keywords:
Ukrainian Cossacks, Jozef Szujski, Krakow Historical School, History of Poland, Tsetsora, KhotynAbstract
The purpose of this article is to analyze and highlight the views of the prominent Polish historian, one of the founders of the Krakow historical school, Jozef Szujski, on the history of the Ukrainian Cossacks at the beginning of the seventeenth century, expressed in the second volume of «The History of Poland in Recent Studies», published in 1862, as well the perception of Tsetsora and Khotyn events, published in an article under the same name, printed in 1877. The main task of the author is to determine how Jozef Szujski estimated the importance of the Ukrainian Cossacks for the historical development of the Commonwealth at the beginning of the seventeenth century, and how he assessed and described the events under Tsetsora in 1620 and Khotin in 1621, which place was assigned to the Ukrainian Cossacks and their prominent representative – Hetman P. Konashevich-Sagaidachny. The methodology of the research is based on the general scientific principles of systematicity, reliability, historicism, logic. Biographical, comparative-historical, and comparative-textual methods were used for profound analysis of the scholar's scientific work. The scientific novelty of the research is that for the first time the scientific work of the outstanding representative of the Krakow School of History, Jozef Szujski, was analyzed for the first time through the prism of his views on the history of the Ukrainian Cossacks from 1619 to 1621 and in the general context of the history of the Commonwealth. The specificity of the Cossack perception as well as its reflection in the synthetic and specialized work of the scientist is highlighted. Conclusions. The analysis of «History of Poland ...» suggests that Jozef Szujski concentrated, first of all, on the socio-political side of historical events, which is characteristic of the Krakow historical school, but, unlike M. Bobzhinsky, he devoted considerable attention to military aspects of history and the Commonwealth. It was important for the historian to comprehensively describe the history of his own state through the prism of international relations, internal social-political processes and military actions as the agents of these processes. On the one hand, the Cossacks received a negative assessment due to unlawful, unauthorized military actions that damaged diplomatic relations with the Ottoman Empire in a difficult time for the Commonwealth. On the other hand, the historian noted the assistance of the Ukrainian Cossacks in the defense of the Commonwealth, although he emphasized on the negative features and the disastrous consequences of their assistance to the state, which is particularly clearly reflected in the course of the battle at Khotyn. An analysis of the history of the Ukrainian Cossacks in the events of the Tsetsora battle and Khotyn War in the brochure under the same name makes it possible to state that Jozef Szujski paid much less attention to this issue, comparing it with the «History of Poland ...», his statements were more carefull, without expressing controversial remarks regarding their role and significance in the battle, he added new small details related to the Cossack subject and made new judgments. However, information on Cossack topics in general, unfortunately, is not enough. One can assume that the interpretation of events by Jozef Szujski changed, first of all, given the patriotic and educational purpose of this work, the new socio-political processes in the Krakow historical environment, and the final departure of the historian from the romantic views of J. Levelel, which took place in the 70-ies of the 19th century.
References
Ruda, 2007 – Ruda O. Vysvitlennia istorii Ukrainy u pratsiakh Yuzefa Shuiskoho [The History of Ukraine in Works of Józef Szujski] // Pivdennyi arkhiv. Istorychni nauky: zbirnyk naukovykh prats. 2007. Vyp. 26. S. 110–115. [in Ukrainian]
Ruda, 2010 – Ruda O. Ukrainske kozatstvo v interpretatsii polskykh istorykiv kintsia XIX – pershoi tretyny XX stolittia. [The Ukrainian Cossacks in the interpretation of Polish historians of the late XIXth – first third of the XXth century]. Lviv, 2010. S. 98–103. [in Ukrainian]
Sinkevych, 2006 – Sinkevych Ye. Ukrainska problematyka v doslidzhenniakh i praktychnii diialnosti krakivskoi istorychnoi shkoly [Ukrainian Issues in Researches and Practical Activities of the Krakow Historical School] // Pivdennyi arkhiv. Istorychni nauky: zbirnyk naukovykh prats. 2007. Vyp. 26. S. 117–121. [in Ukrainian]
Sinkevych, 2010 – Sinkevych Ye. Krakivska istorychna shkola v polskii istoriohrafii. Vydannia 2-he (utochnene i dopovnene) [Krakow Historical School in Polish Historiography. Edition 2-th (specified and supplemented)]. Mykolaiv, 2010. 332 s. [in Ukrainian]
Buszko,1969 – Buszko J. Historycy «szkoly krakowskiej» w życiu politycznym Galicji / Spór o historyczna szkołę krakjwską. W stulecie katedry historii Polski UJ [Historians of the «Krakow school» in the political life of Galicia. / A dispute over the Krakow historical school. On the centenary of the history of Polish history at the Jagiellonian University]. 1869 – 1969. Kraków, 1969. S. 192-205. [in Polish]
Dembiński, 1908 – Dembiński B. Szujski i jego synteza dziejów. Kraków [Szujski and his synthesis of history], 1908. 24 s. [in Polish]
Maternicki, 2009 – Maternicki J., Historia i życie narodu. Poglądy i postawy historyków polskich XIX i XX wieku. [History and life of the nation. Opinions and attitudes of Polish historians of the XIXth and XXth centuries.] Rzeszów, 2009. S. 144–157. [in Polish]
Michalak, 1987 – Michalak Н. Józef Szujski 1835 – 1883. Światopogląd i dzialanie. [Józef Szujski 1835 – 1883. Worldview and action.] Łódż, 1987. 300 s. [in Polish]
Słoczyński, 2017 – Słoczyński H. Krytyczna interpretacja dziejów narodowych Józefa Szujskiego a Upadek Polski Jana Matejki. / Krakowska szkoła historyczna a Polskie Towarystwo Historyczne. Studia historiograficzne. Warszawa-Kraków, [The critical interpretation of the national history of Józef Szujski and the Fall of Poland by Jan Matejko. / Krakow Historical School and Polish Historical Products Historiographical Studies] 2017. S. 217–240. [in Polish]
Smolka, 1883 – Smolka S. Józef Szujski – jego stanowisko w literaturze i spoleczenstwie [Józef Szujski – his position in literature and society.]. Kraków, 1883. 126 s. [in Polish]
Smoleński, 1887 – Smoleński W. Szkoły historyczne w Polsce : główne kierunki poglądów na przeszłoś [Historical schools in Poland: main directions of views on the past.]. Warszawa, 1898. 160 s. [in Polish]
Stępnik, 1998 – Stępnik A. Ukraina i stosunki polsko-ukraińskie w syntezach i podręcznikach dziejow ojczystych okresu porozbiorowego 1795 – 1918, [Ukraine and Polish-Ukrainian relations in the synthesis and textbooks of national history of the post-partition period 1795 – 1918] Lublin, 1998. S. 168–169. [in Polish]
Szocki, 1991 – Szocki J. Zainteresowania księzbór Józefa Szujskiego (1835 – 1883) [Interests of The Library of Józef Szujski (1835 – 1883) // A review of the West Pomeranian region] // Pszegląd zachodniopomorski. T. VI (XXXV). Rok. 1991. Zeszyt 3. S. 79–91. [in Polish]
Szujski,1864 – Szujski J. Dzieje Polski podług ostatnich badań. [History of Poland according to the recent research], Lwów, 1864. T. 3. Królowie wolno obrani. Cz. 1. r. 1572 – 1668. 497 s. [in Polish]
Szujski,1871 – Szujski J. Chocim i Cecora [Chocim and Cecora]. Kraków, 1871. 18 s. [in Polish]
Teczkі osobowe – Józef Szujski, Archiwum Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego [Personal files – Józef Szujski, Archives of the Jagiellonian University] – S II 619. [in Polish]
Zamorski, 2015 – Zamorski K. Historyzm i narodziny krakowskiej szkoły historycznej. Józef Szujski. [Historicism and the birth of the Krakow historical school. Józef Szujski.] / Józef Szujski (1835 – 1883) Materiały z posiedzenia naukowego w dniu 25 listopada 2013 r. Kraków, 2015. S. 51–61. [in Polish]
Zoll, 1884 – Zoll F. Spis prac naukowych, literackich i politycznych J. Szujskiego, ogąoszonych drukiem bąndż osobno, bąndż w pismach czasowych [List of J. Szujski's scientific, literary and political works, published in print either separately, or in the periodicals.]. Kraków, Redakcya «Czasu», 1884. 8 s. [in Polish]