HISTORIOGRAPHICAL IMAGE OF TADEUSZ KOSTIUSHKO ON THE PAGES OF LVIV'S POLISH AND UKRAINIAN SCIENTIFIC JOURNALS DURING THE LATE XIX – EARLY XX CENTURIES
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058x.9.150363Keywords:
historiographical image, historical journal, Tadeusz Kosciuszko, «Kwartalnik Historyczny», «Notes of the T. Shevchenko Scientific Society».Abstract
The article's purpose. To reconstruct the historiographical image of Tadeusz Kostiushko, which was formed on the pages of the Polish and Ukrainian scientific historical press of Lviv at the end of the XIXth to the beginning of the XX century. On the basis of materials – the content of the two most significant for that time Polish and Ukrainian historical sciences magazines «Kwartalnik Historyczny» (published in Lviv in 1887 – 1939) and «Notes of the T. Shevchenko Scientific Society» (published in Lviv in 1892 – 1937). The methodology of the research is based on the principles of historicism, systemicity, science, verification, author's objectivity, moderate narrative constructivism, as well as the use of general scientific (analysis, synthesis, generalization) and special-historical (historical-genetic, historical-typological, historical-systemic ) methods. Scientific novelty is that for the first time attempt was made to reconstruct and compare the historiographical image of Tadeusz Kostiushko, which was formed on the pages of the Polish and Ukrainian scientific historical press of Lviv at the end of the XIXth to the beginning of the XX century. The conclusions. The study of texts on Tadeusz Kostiushko in the periodicals «Kwartalnik Historyczny» and «Notes of the T. Shevchenko Scientific Society» makes it possible to conclude that the authors of these editions, acting on principles of the positivist methodology, consistently de-mythologizing the image of the Polish national hero and tried to defend the objectivism of historical science, even if it contradicted the state of affairs at the moment and the political challenges of time
References
Boldyr, Chernov, 1996 – Boldyr S. P., Chernov E. A. Istoriograficheskiy obraz: opyt rasshireniya metodologicheskogo arsenala nauki istorii istoricheskogo poznaniya [Historiographical image: the experience of expanding the methodological arsenal of the science of the history of historical knowledge] // Ukrainska istorychna nauka na porozi XXI v. Kharkivskyi istoriohrafichnyi zbirnyk. Kh.: Avesta, 1996. Vyp. 2. S. 91–102.
Dembiński, 1897 – Dembiński B. [Рец.:] K. [T. Korzon]. Kościuszko. Biografia z dokumentów wysnuta. Kraków, 1894 [Kosciuszko. Biography created on the basis of documents] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1897. S. 857–864.
Khalbvaks, 2005 – Khalbvaks M. Kollektivnaya iistoricheskaya pamyat [Collective and historical memory] [Elektronnyi resurs] / per. s fr. M. Gabovicha // Pamyat o voyne 60 let spustya: Rossiya. Germaniya. Evropa. M. 2005. URL: http://magazines.russ.ru/nz/2005/2/ha2.html (data zvernennia: 21.08.2018).
Kolbuszewska, 2007 – Kolbuszewska J., Twórczość recenzyjna Tadeusza Korzona na łamach «Kwartalnika Historycznego» [Review activity of Tadeusz Korzon in the pages of the «Kwartalnik Historyczny»] [w:] Wielokulturowe środowisko historyczne Lwowa w XIX i XX w. , t. 5, pod red. J. Maternickiego, Rzeszów 2007, s. 263.
Korzon, 1889 – Korzon T. [Рец.:] Zur Geschichte der Räumung Belgiens und des polnischen Aufstandes (174) nach Lacy's Vorträgen an den Kaiser von Dr. H. R. v. Zeissberg [The history of the evacuation of Belgium and the Polish uprising] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1889. S. 585–588.
Korzon, 1908 – KorzonT. [Рец.:] Kozłowski W. Pobyt Kościuszki i Niemcewicza w Ameryce w łatach 1737 i 1738 rr. [The stay of Kościuszko and Niemcewicz in America in the patches 1737 and 1738.] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1908. S. 469–473.
Korzon, 1912 – KorzonT. [Рец.:] Kozłowski W. Pierwszy rok służby amerykańskiej Kościuszki (18.10.1776 – 17.10.1777); Kościuszko w West-Point; ostatnie łata amerykańskiej służby Kościuszki (1781 – 1784) [The first year of the American service of Kosciuszko (18.10.1776 – 17.10.1777); Kosciuszko in West-Point; the last patch of the American service of Kosciuszko (1781 - 1784) ] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1912. S. 188–203.
Korzon, 1917 – Korzon T. Vademecum Kościuszkowskie: Przewodnik dla kompilatorów czyli Biografii Tadeusza Kościuszki [Kosciuszko Vademecum: the guide for compilers orBiography Tadeusz Kosciuszko] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1917. S. 376–425.
Kozłowski, 1898 – Kozłowski W. Kościuszko, Kołłątaj i Rewolucya Francuska [Kosciuszko, Kołłątaj and the French Revolution] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1898. S. 818–842.
Leont'eva O. B. Istoricheskaya pamyat' i obrazy proshlogo v rossijskoj kul'ture XIX – nachala XX v. [Historical memory and images of the past in Russian culture of the XIX - early XX century.] Samara, 2011. 448 c.
Malinowski, 1861 – Malinowski M. Die Kirchen- und Staats-Satzungen bezüglich des griechischen-katholisch Ritus der Ruthenen in Galizien [Church and state statutes concerning the Greek-Catholic rite Ruthenians in Galicia]. Lemberg: Drukerei des Stauropigianischen Instituts, 1861. 890 s.
Modelski, 1937 – Modelski T. E. Towarzystwo Historyczne 1914 – 1924 [Historical Society 1914 – 1924] // Kwartalnik Historyczny.1937. S. 41–88.
Nora. 1999 – Nora P. Problematika mest pamyati [Elektronnyi resurs] [The problem of memory places] // Frantsiya-pamyat / P. Nora. M. Ozuf. Zh. de Pyuimezh. M. Vinok. SPb. 1999. S. 17–50 URL: http://ec-dejavu.ru/m-2/ Memory-Nora.html (data zvernennia: 21.08.2018).
Posokhov, 2013 – Posokhov S. I. Istoriograficheskiye obrazy: variant dekonstruktsii (na materialakh istoriografii rossiyskikh universitetov) [Historiographic images: a variant of deconstruction (on materials of historiography of Russian universities)] // Elektronnyy nauchno-obrazovatelnyy zhurnal «Istoriya». 2013. T. 4. Vypusk 2 (18) [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http://history.jes.su/s207987840000479-5-1 (data zvernennia: 28.06.2017).
Repina, 2004 – Repina L. P. Istoricheskaya pamyat i sovremennaya istoriografiya [Historical memory and modern historiography] // Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya. 2004. № 5. S. 33–45.
Riker, 2004 – Riker P. Pamyat. istoriya. zabveniye [Memory, history, oblivion]. М., 2004. 728 s.
Shchurat, 1921 – Shchurat V. Ukrainski tradytsii pro pokhodzhennia Kostiushka [Ukrainian tradition about Kosciuszko’sorigin] // Zapysky NTSH. – Lviv, 1921. T. 131. – S. 231–247.
Sprawozdania, 1895 – Sprawozdania z posiedzeń Towarzystwa Historycznego [Reports of the meetings of the Historical Society] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1895. S. 190–193.
Sprawozdania, 1901 – Sprawozdania z posiedzeń Towarzystwa Historycznego od 16 listopada 1901 r. [Reports of the meetings of the Historical Society] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1901. S. 617–618.
Śreniowska, 1964 – Śreniowska K., Kościuszko. Kształtowanie poglądów na bohatera narodowego 1794-1894 [Kosciuszko. Shaping views on the national hero]. Warszawa, 1964. S.100–101.
X., 1889 – X. [Рец.:] Baudouin R. de Courtenay. Nowe materialy do życia Kościuszki [New materials to life Kosciuszko] // Kwartalnik Historyczny. 1889. S. 592–593.
