THE TRUE ORTHODOX CHURCH IN THE SCIENTIFIC DISCOURSE OF THE SECOND HALF OF THE 20TH – THE FIRST QUARTER OF THE 21ST CENTURY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.39.365002Abstract
The phenomenon of the True Orthodox Church (TOC), also known as the “catacomb church”, belongs to the complex and controversial plots of the history of Orthodoxy in the 20th century, as it arose in the context of the radical transformation of state-church relations after the 1917 revolution and the formation of opposition among some of the clergy and laity to the policy of loyalty of Moscow Patriarchate towards the Soviet government. The long-term illegal existence of underground Orthodox communities, the limited nature of the source base, and the ideological bias of early research led to the uneven development of scientific understanding of this phenomenon. The purpose of the article is to critically analyze the main stages and directions of studying the True Orthodox Church, to compare key research approaches, and to identify prospects for further studies. The methodological basis of the study is a complex of principles of historicism, problematics, and interdisciplinarity using special historical methods – historical comparative, problematic chronological, and historiographic analysis. The scientific novelty of the article consists in the systematization of the main directions of studying the TOC in the Soviet, Russian, and Ukrainian historiography, a critical comparison of their methodological approaches and source capabilities, as well as in determining the specifics of the Ukrainian research tradition formation in this area. Conclusions. The analysis of historiography shows that the study of the True Orthodox Church was formed gradually and unevenly. The Soviet historiography considered underground Orthodox groups mainly through the prism of the state’s anti-religious policy and did not form a coherent scientific concept of the TOC, although it accumulated a significant empirical material. A new stage began after the opening of archives in the 1990s, when the Russian researchers introduced a significant array of documents of repressive bodies into scientific circulation and initiated a systematic study of the catacomb movement. Since the 1990s the Ukrainian historiography has gradually formed its own research tradition, based mainly on archival and investigative materials and regional studies. At the same time, the issue under study remains insufficiently generalized: a significant part of the sources has not yet been introduced into scientific circulation, and regional studies require synthetic understanding. Further studies should be aimed at expanding the source base, clarifying the conceptual and terminological apparatus, and creating generalizing studies that will enable scholars to make a holistic reconstruction of the history of the TOC in the context of church life in the Soviet era.
Key words: True Orthodox Church, Catacomb Church, Church Underground, Orthodoxy in the USSR, historiography, state-church relations.
References
Beglov, A. L. (2004). Tserkovnoe podpolie 1920 – 1940-kh godov v SSSR v kontekste gosudarstvenno-tserkovnykh otnoshenii [Church Underground of the 1920s – 1940s in the USSR in the Context of State–Church Relations]. (Candidate dissertation). Moskva. [in Russian].
Beglov, A. (2018). V poiskakh ‘bezgreshnykh katakomb’. Tserkovnoe podpolie v SSSR [In Search of ‘Sinless Catacombs’: The Church Underground in the USSR]. Moskva: ROSSPEN. [in Russian].
Bilokin, S. (2008). O. Anatolii Zhurakovskyi i kyivski yosiflyany. Dokumentalne doslidzhennia [Anatolii Zhurakovskyi and the Kyiv Josephites: A Documentary Study]. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy. [in Ukrainian].
Bochkov, P. V. (2023). Pamiati Iriny Ivanovny Osipovoi [In Memory of Irina Ivanovna Osipova]. Christian Schism Review, 1 (1), 81–92. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24412/2949-642X-2023-0050 [in Russian].
Demianov, A. I. (1977). Istinno-pravoslavnoe khristianstvo. Kritika ideologii i deiatelnosti [True Orthodox Christianity: Critique of Ideology and Activity]. Voronezh: Izdatelstvo Voronezhskogo universiteta. [in Russian].
Forostiuk, O. D. (2000). Pravove rehuliuvannia derzhavno-tserkovnykh vidnosyn u radianskii Ukraini v 1917 – 1941 rokakh (na materiali Donetskoho rehionu) [Legal Regulation of State–Church Relations in Soviet Ukraine in 1917 – 1941 (Based on the Donetsk Region)]. Luhansk: RVV LIVS. [in Ukrainian].
Forostiuk, O. D. (2001). Pravove rehuliuvannia derzhavno-tserkovnykh vidnosyn u radianskii Ukraini v 1917 – 1941 rokakh (na materiali Donetskoho rehionu) [Legal Regulation of State–Church Relations in Soviet Ukraine in 1917 – 1941 (Based on Donetsk Region)]. (Candidate dissertation). Luhansk. [in Ukrainian].
Ioann (Snychev), arkhimandrit. (1993). Tserkovnye raskoly v Russkoi Tserkvi 20-kh i 30-kh gg. XX stoletiia – grigorianskii, iaroslavskii, iosiflianskii, viktorianskii i drugie, ikh osobennosti i istoriia [Church Schisms in the Russian Church in the 1920s – 1930s – Gregorian, Yaroslavl, Josephite, Victorian and the others, their Features and History]. Sortavala. [in Russian].
Klibanov, A. I. (1969). Religioznoe sektantstvo i sovremennost (Sotsiologicheskie i istoricheskie ocherki) [Religious Sectarianism and Modernity: Sociological and Historical Essays]. Moskva: Nauka. [in Russian].
Klibanov, A. I. (1973). Religioznoe sektantstvo v proshlom i nastoiashchem [Religious Sectarianism in the Past and Present]. Moskva: Nauka. [in Russian].
Kyrydon, A. (2012a). Istinno-Pravoslavnaia Tserkov: diskurs sovremennoi istoriografii (Doklad na mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii ‘Tserkovnoe podpole v SSSR’, Chernigov, 18 noiabria 2011 g.) [True Orthodox Church: Discourse of Contemporary Historiography (Paper Presented at the International Scientific Conference ‘Church Underground in the USSR’, Chernihiv, November 18, 2011)]. Vera i zhizn (Chernigov), 19, 56–72. [in Russian].
Kyrydon, A. M. (2012b). Retseptsiia Istynno-Pravoslavnoi Tserkvy v suchasnii istoriohrafii [Reception of the True Orthodox Church in Contemporary Historiography]. Slovianskyi visnyk (Rivne), 14, 38–44. [in Ukrainian].
Loginov, O. (2007). Likvidatsiia ‘ioannitskoho’ rukhu v 1920 – 1950-kh rr. na Vinnychchyni [Liquidation of the ‘Ioannite’ Movement in the 1920s – 1950s in Vinnytsia Region]. Z arkhiviv VUChK–GPU–NKVD–KGB, 2 (29), 18–38. [in Ukrainian].
Loginov, O. V. (2012). ‘Biites Drakona!’: Katakombna Tserkva na Vinnychchyni u 20 stolitti [‘Fear the Dragon!’: The Catacomb Church in Vinnytsia Region in the 20th Century]. Vinnytsia: TOV “Kheops”. [in Ukrainian].
Mazyrin, A. V. (2005). Vnutrennie konflikty v Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi vtoroi poloviny 1920-kh – 1930-kh godov (v svete pozitsii vysshikh ierarkhov) [Internal Conflicts in the Russian Orthodox Church in the Second Half of the 1920s – 1930s (in Light of the Position of the Highest Hierarchs)]. (Candidate dissertation). Moskva. [in Russian].
Mazyrin, A. (2006). Vysshie ierarkhi o preemstve vlasti v Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi v 1920 – 1930-kh godakh [The Highest Hierarchs on the Succession of Power in the Russian Orthodox Church in the 1920s – 1930s]. Moskva: Izdatelstvo PSTGU. [in Russian].
Mazyryn, A. V., & Kosik, O. V. (Eds.). (2011). Alchushchie pravdy: Materialy tserkovnoi polemiki 1927 goda [Hungering for Truth: Materials of Church Polemics of 1927]. Moskva: Izdatelstvo PSTGU. [in Russian].
Mitrokhin, L. N. (1961). Reaktsionnaia deiatelnost ‘Istinno-pravoslavnoi tserkvi’ na Tambovshchine [Reactionary Activity of the ‘True Orthodox Church’ in the Tambov Region]. Voprosy istorii religii i ateizma, 9, 144–160. [in Russian].
Mykhailutsa, M. I. (2002). NKVS, ‘sprava’ IPTs ta profesor V. P. Filatov (na materialakh arkhivu USBU v Odeskii oblasti) [NKVD, the ‘Case’ of the True Orthodox Church, and Professor V. P. Filatov (Based on the Materials of the Archive of the Security Service of Ukraine in Odesa Region)]. Intelihentsiia i vlada, 1 (2), Part II, 45–48. [in Ukrainian].
Mykhailutsa, M. I. (2012a). ‘Odesskaia gruppa “IPTs” 1935 g.: tragistsenarii sovetskikh spets sluzhb [‘Odessa Group of the “True Orthodox Church” 1935: A Tragic Scenario of Soviet Special Services]. Bylye gody, 4 (26), 48–56. [in Russian].
Mykhailutsa, M. (2012b). ‘Ultra-pravoslavni opozytsionery’ na Odeshchyni (30-ti roky 20 st.) [‘Ultra-Orthodox Oppositionists’ in Odesa Region (the 1930s)]. Pivdennyi zakhid. Odesyka, 13, 229–238 [in Ukrainian].
Mykhailutsa, М., Trygub, О. (2020). Odesa Orthodox Movement vs ‘Bilshovyk Propaganda by Action’ (the early 1920s). Eminak, 2 (30), 155–166. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2020.2(30).416 [in Ukrainian].
Nikolskaia, Z. A. (1961). K kharakteristike techeniia tak nazyvaemykh istinno-pravoslavnykh khristian [On the Characteristics of the So-Called True Orthodox Christians Movement]. Voprosy istorii religii i ateizma, 9, 161–188 [in Russian].
Nuikina, E. Yu. (2024). Arkhivno-sledstvennye dela po obvineniiu dukhovenstva Russkoi pravoslavnoi tserkvi (1917 – 1930-e gg.). Istochnikovedcheskoe issledovanie [Archival-Investigative Files on Charges against the Clergy of the Russian Orthodox Church (1917 – the 1930s): A Source Study]. Moskva; Sankt-Peterburg: Institut slavianovedeniia Rossiiskoi akademii nauk; Nestor-Istoriia. [in Russian].
Osipova, I. I. (1998). ‘Skvoz ogn muchenii i vodu slez…’. Goneniia na Istinno-Pravoslavnuiu Tserkov: po materialam sledstvennykh i lagernykh del zakliuchennykh [‘Through the Fire of Suffering and the Water of Tears…’. Persecutions of the True Orthodox Church: Based on Investigative and Camp Files of Prisoners]. Moskva: Serebrianye niti [in Russian].
Osipova, I. I. (Ed.). (2008). ‘O, Premiloserdyi… Budi s nami neotstupno…’. Vospominaniia veruiushchikh Istinno-Pravoslavnoi (Katakombnoi) Tserkvi. Konets 1920-kh – nachalo 1970-kh godov [‘O Most Merciful… Be with Us Unceasingly…’. Memoirs of Believers of the True Orthodox (Catacomb) Church. Late 1920s – Early 1970s]. Moskva: Bratonezh [in Russian].
Pashchenko, V. O. (1994). Svoboda sovisti v Ukraini: mify i fakty 20 – 30-kh rokiv [Freedom of Conscience in Ukraine: Myths and Facts of the 1920s – 1930s]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Protsenko, P. (1998). Mif ob istinnoi tserkvi [The Myth of the True Church]. Vestnik russkogo khristianskogo dvizheniia (Paris), 5–6 (179), 137–150. [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (1996). Russkaia pravoslavnaia tserkov i religioznaia politika sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1939 – 1964 gg. [The Russian Orthodox Church and the Religious Policy of the Soviet State in 1939 – 1964]. (Doctoral dissertation abstract). Sankt-Peterburg [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (1999). Iosiflianstvo: techenie v Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi [Josephitism: A Movement in the Russian Orthodox Church]. Sankt-Peterburg: NITs “Memorial” [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (2000). Russkaia Pravoslavnaia Tserkov pri Staline i Khrushcheve (gosudarstvenno-tserkovnye otnosheniia v SSSR v 1939 – 1964 godakh) [The Russian Orthodox Church under Stalin and Khrushchev (State–Church Relations in the USSR in 1939 – 1964)]. Moskva: Krutitskoe patriarshee podvore; Obshchestvo liubitelei tserkovnoi istorii. [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (2006). Sudby iosiflianskikh pastyrei. Iosiflianskoe dvizhenie Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi v sudbakh ego uchastnikov. Arkhivnye dokumenty [Fates of Josephite Pastors: The Josephite Movement of the Russian Orthodox Church in the Lives of Its Participants. Archival Documents]. St. Peterburg: Satis. [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (2010). Istinno-pravoslavnaia tserkov na Ukraine [The True Orthodox Church in Ukraine]. Tserkovnye vedomosti. URL: https://bit.ly/4sZMDRe [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V. (2011). Iosiflianskoe dvizhenie v Kieve v pervoi polovine 1930-kh gg.: sviashchennik Dimitrii Shpakovskii i episkop Damaskin (Tsedrik) [The Josephite Movement in Kyiv in the First Half of the 1930s: Priest Dimitrii Shpakovskii and Bishop Damaskin (Tsedrik)]. Trudy Kyivskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 14, 204–222. [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V., & Anashkin, D. P. (2013). Pravoslavnoe tserkovnoe soprotivlenie v SSSR. Biograficheskii spravochnik, 1927 – 1988 gg. [Orthodox Church Resistance in the USSR: A Biographical Reference Book, 1927 – 1988]. Moskva: ROSSPEN. [in Russian].
Shkarovskii, M. V., & Vedeneev, D. V. (2017). Operativnaia razrabotka i repressii sovetskikh organov gosudarstvennoi bezopasnosti protiv religioznogo techeniia ‘podgornovtsev’ (‘stefanovtsev’) v 1930 – 1950-e gg. [Operational Development and Repressions of Soviet State Security Bodies against the Religious Movement of ‘Podgornovtsy’ (‘Stefanovtsy’) in the 1930s – 1950s]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 75, 94–119. [in Russian].
Shumylo, S. (2011). V katakombakh. Pravoslavnoe podpole v SSSR. Konspekt po istorii Istinno-pravoslavnoi tserkvi v SSSR [In the Catacombs: Orthodox Underground in the USSR. A Compendium on the History of the True Orthodox Church in the USSR]. Lutsk: Teren [in Russian].
Shumylo, V. (2001). Skhiarkhimandrit Lavrentii i ego vremia. Ocherk tserkovnoi istorii Chernigovshchiny (1868 – 1950 gg.) [Schema-Archimandrite Lavrentii and His Time: An Essay on the Church History of Chernihiv Region (1868 – 1950)]. Chernigov: Russkoe Pravoslavnoe Izdatelstvo “Vera i Zhizn”. [in Russian].
Shumylo, V. (2015). Sluzhenie Tserkvi sviashchennomuchenika episkopa Damaskina (Tsedrika) do ego khirtonii v 1923 godu [Service of the Church of the Hieromartyr Bishop Damaskin (Tsedrik) before His Consecration in 1923]. Rocznik Teologiczny, 1, 5–26 [in Russian].
Shumylo, V. (2016). Sluzhenie Tserkvi sviashchennomuchenika episkopa Damaskina (Tsedrika) posle ego khirtonii v 1923 godu [Service of the Church of the Hieromartyr Bishop Damaskin (Tsedrik) after His Consecration in 1923]. Rocznik Teologiczny, 2, 173–218 [in Russian].
Shumylo, V. (2019). Skhiarkhimandryt Lavrentii (Proskura) – chlen Istynno-Pravoslavnoi Tserkvy na Chernihivshchyni [Schema-Archimandrite Lavrentii (Proskura) as a Member of the True Orthodox Church in Chernihiv Region]. Siverianskyi litopys, 4–5, 67–80 [in Ukrainian].
Shumylo, V. (2020a). Istynno-Pravoslavna Tserkva na Chernihivshchyni ta ihumen Alipii (Yakovenko) [The True Orthodox Church in Chernihiv Region and Hegumen Alipii (Yakovenko)]. Siverianskyi litopys, 1, 124–137. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3732582 [in Ukrainian].
Shumylo, V. (2020b). Nevidome ranshe Velykopisne poslannia arkhiepyskopa Chernihivskoho Pakhomiia (Kedrova) yak dzherelo do yoho biohrafii [Previously Unknown Lenten Message of Archbishop Pakhomii (Kedrov) of Chernihiv as a Source for His Biography]. Siverianskyi litopys, 4, 41–59. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4018368 [in Ukrainian].
Shumylo, V. (2021a). Chernihivske zaslannia S.O. Nilusa 1926 – 1928 rr.: za materialamy slidchoi spravy ODPU [The Chernihiv Exile of S.O. Nilus (1926 – 1928): Based on the Materials of the OGPU Investigative File]. Siverianskyi litopys, 2, 19–30. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4740145 [in Ukrainian].
Shumylo, V.V. (2021b). Istynno-pravoslavna (katakombna) tserkva na Chernihivshchyni u 20 – 30-kh rr. 20 st. [The True Orthodox (Catacomb) Church in Chernihiv Region in the 1920s – 1930s]. (Candidate dissertation). Chernihiv. [in Ukrainian].
Sikorskaia, L. E., & Osipova, I. I. (2022). Novomucheniki i ispovedniki istinnogo pravoslaviia Ukrainy. Po materialam sledstvennogo dela Istinno-Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi 1931 goda [New Martyrs and Confessors of True Orthodoxy in Ukraine: Based on the Investigative File of the True Orthodox Church of 1931]. Moskva: Bratonezh. [in Russian].
SSA SSU – Sectoral State Archive of the Security Service of Ukraine. Fund 13. List 1. File 390 “Obvinitelnoe zakliuchenie po delu kontrrevoliutsionnoi, tserkovno-monarkhicheskoi organizatsii ‘Buevtsev’. g. Voronezh. 1930 g.” [Indictment in the Case of the Counter-Revolutionary, Church-Monarchist Organization ‘Buevtsev’. Voronezh, 1930]. [in Russian].
Trygub, O. (2009a). ‘Deklaratsiia’ mytropolyta Serhiia 1927 r. ta vynyknennia antyserhiivskoi opozytsii v Ukraini [The ‘Declaration’ of Metropolitan Sergius of 1927 and the Emergence of Anti-Sergian Opposition in Ukraine]. Hrani, 4 (66), July–August, 31–35. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2009b). ‘Istynno-pravoslavna tserkva’ v Ukraini (1927 – 1931 rr.) [The ‘True Orthodox Church’ in Ukraine (1927 – 1931)]. Gileya, 20, 89–104. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2009c). ‘Istynno-pravoslavna tserkva’ na Khersonshchyni (1927 – 1939 rr.) [The ‘True Orthodox Church’ in Kherson Region (1927 – 1939)]. In Pivden Ukrainy: etnoistorychnyi, movnyi, kulturnyi ta relihiinyi vymiry. Materialy II mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii (Odesa, 10–11 kvitnia 2009 r.) (pp. 320–325). Odesa: VMV. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2009d). Rozghrom ukrainskoi tserkovnoi opozytsii v Rosiiskii pravoslavnii tserkvi (1922 – 1939 rr.) [The Defeat of the Ukrainian Church Opposition in the Russian Orthodox Church (1922 – 1939)]. Mykolaiv: TOV “Firma Ilion”. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2013). Istynno-Pravoslavna Tserkva Mykolaivshchyny v leshchatakh totalitarnoho rezhymu (1927 – 1939 rr.) [The True Orthodox Church of Mykolaiv Region in the Grip of the Totalitarian Regime (1927 – 1939)]. In Reabilitovani istoriieiu. Mykolaivska oblast, (book 6. pp. 46–55). Kyiv–Mykolaiv: Svitohliad. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2019). Slidamy istinno-pravoslavnykh (tiazka dolia chernytsi Darii Pidmohylnoyi) [Following the Trail of the True Orthodox (The Difficult Fate of Nun Daria Pidmohylnа)]. Pivden Ukrainy: etnoistorychnyi, movnyi, kulturnyi ta relihiinyi vymiry: zbirka naukovykh prats, 7, 515–522. [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O., & Bazhan, O. (2026). Development of True Orthodox Church in Kyiv Region (1927 – 1931). Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, 46 (1), 111–135. DOI: https://doi.org/10.55221/2693-2229.2712 [in English].
Vedeneev, D. (2016). Ateisty v mundirakh: sovetskie spets sluzhby i religioznaia sfera Ukrainy [Atheists in Uniform: Soviet Special Services and the Religious Sphere of Ukraine]. Moskva: OOO “TD Algoritm”. [in Russian].
Vedeneev, D. V., & Shkarovskii, M. V. (2016a). Repressivnye aktsii organov gosudarstvennoi bezopasnosti protiv obshchin ‘Istinno-pravoslavnoi tserkvi’ v Ukrainskoi SSR (1944 – 1953 gg.) [Repressive Actions of State Security Bodies against Communities of the True Orthodox Church in the Ukrainian SSR (1944 – 1953)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2 (69), 49–65. [in Russian].
Vedeneev, D. V., & Shkarovskii, M. V. (2016b). Repressivnye aktsii organov gosudarstvennoi bezopasnosti protiv obshchin ‘Istinno-pravoslavnoi tserkvi’ v Ukrainskoi SSR (1944 – 1953 gg.) (okonchanie) [Repressive Actions of State Security Bodies against Communities of the True Orthodox Church in the Ukrainian SSR (1944 – 1953) (Conclusion)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 3 (70), 77–92. [in Russian].
Vedeneev, D. V. (2017). Dokumenty orhaniv derzhavnoi bezpeky yak dzherelo doslidzhennia sotsiokulturnykh osoblyvostei ‘katakombnoi’ techii u pravoslavi v Ukrainskii RSR u 1920-ti – 1950-ti rr. [Documents of State Security Bodies as a Source for Studying Sociocultural Features of the ‘Catacomb’ Trend in Orthodoxy in the Ukrainian SSR in the 1920s – 1950s]. Bibliotekoznavstvo. Dokumentoznavstvo. Informolohiia, 1, 26–36. [in Ukrainian].
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
